OPINION: Cluster Munitions Are No More Inhumane Than Any Other Battlefield Weapon

The National Rifle Association of America (NRA) uses the slogan: “guns don’t kill people, people kill people.” Using that argument, what’s the problem with cluster munitions?

July 15, 2023

This handout picture dated September 20, 2016 shows Soldiers from Alpha Battery, 1st Battalion, 82nd Field Artillery Regiment, 1st Armored Brigade Combat Team, 1st Cavalry Division, participate in a load exercise directed by the 210th Field Artillery Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division. Handout / DVIDS / AFP

The news that the US is providing Ukraine with cluster munitions has caused objections from a number of politicians and campaign groups. This opposition derives from the same sound humanitarian reasons that led to the creation of the 2010 Convention on Cluster Munitions (CCM). In fact, in my view, while the CCM is a very worthy treaty it is based on the historical use of “dumb” munitions, used indiscriminately and in tactically inappropriate circumstances and takes no account of how things have changed.

What is a cluster munition?

The CCM defines cluster munition as “a conventional munition that is designed to disperse or release explosive submunitions, each weighing less than 20 kilograms.” Thus, a cluster munition consists of a carrier container (the body of an artillery round, rocket or air-delivered canister) from which smaller sub-munitions are dispensed to strike a target.

The dispenser releases the submunitions above the target at a pre-ordained height, the submunitions spread as they fall, exploding when they hit a target or the ground. The spread is called the “footprint” the size of which is affected by the number of sub-munitions contained in the carrier, the height and angle of release.

The standard US submunition is called dual-purpose improved conventional munition, or DPICM. As its name suggests it is dual-purpose because it has effects on both vehicles or materiel as well as personnel. The most recent version, the M77, has a “shaped charge” penetrator and a fragmenting body. Each 155 mm artillery shell carries 88 M77 submunitions.

The Ukraine situation

In the context of the war in Ukraine you have to consider how more effective is the technology being used, the targets and locations in which and against whom the Armed Forces of Ukraine (AFU) will use these weapons.

It seems clear to me that comparing the probable use of cluster munitions in Ukraine in 2023 with the use of similar but technologically inferior weapons during WWII, Vietnam, Lao PDR and even the first Gulf War to be misleading. In considering the case for or against providing Ukraine with the weapons you have to examine how extensively Russian forces have used cluster munitions against civilian populations in Chechnya, Syria and extensively in Ukraine.

The military value of the US dual-purpose improved conventional munition (DPICM) rounds and the way in which the AFU intends to use the munitions in Ukraine is clear and, it seems to me, to render most if not all the issues that formed the basis of the CCM as irrelevant.

Ukraine is currently engaged in its offensive against Russian forces occupying tens of kilometers of trenches, anti-tank obstacles and unmarked minefields. If the offensive fails, then the war will go on because the pressure that success will place on Moscow to sue for peace will disappear.

Ukrainian artillery is critical to break through these Russian defenses, but the AFU has fewer guns than the enemy and limited stocks of ammunition. Studies into cluster munitions, fired from 155 mm artillery (and MLRS), show how much more efficient they are compared with so-called “unitary” high explosive (HE) shells. The US analysis has shown that eight times as many HE rounds are needed to inflict the same amount of damage as a single DPICM shell, particularly against troops in trenches, providing Ukraine with the potential to achieve much greater lethal and suppressive effects for the same number of rounds.

Rights and wrongs

Activist groups object to the use of cluster munitions on four main issues:

Legal – Human Rights Watch (HRW) and others say because of the CCM the use of these weapons is illegal. In fact, the convention is based on an “undertaking” not to use the munition not a legal obligation (unless a nation has produced its own legislation on the subject). If you are not a signatory of the convention, as none of the US, Russia or Ukraine are, then they are not governed by any legal prohibition specific to the munition itself. The intentional use against civilian populations or other non-military targets would be illegal just as it is for any other battlefield weapon.

Reliability – objectors will point to 30-40 percent failure rates among submunitions, based on data that in some cases from 50 or more years ago, although it is true that similar levels of “duds” among weapons fired in Ukraine by Russia have been reported. The modern US DPICM weapons have documented failure rates of less than 2.5 percent – which is actually lower than nearly all the conventional weapons currently employed by either side in Ukraine. That level of failure is totally insignificant when compared with the size of the unexploded munition and landmine contamination the war has already caused and is likely to be encountered on the Russian defensive lines whatever weapons are used.

Accuracy – in the past the accuracy of sub-munition carrying weapons has been a cause for concern but primarily in those air-delivered munitions where the trajectory, height of submunition release and weather conditions often increased the spread of the sub-projectiles. To date the US is only offering to provide 155 mm DPICM to Ukraine which again provides less likelihood of the submunitions “going astray” and the “footprint” from each weapons strike is inherently much smaller with 88 M77 sub-munitions compared with 644 in a HIMARS canister and 247 in a “Rockeye” air-delivered cluster bomb unit (CBU) [obsolete Vietnam War-era CBU-58, a no longer in use – ed.].

Indiscriminate weapon – campaigners against DPICM say it targets indiscriminately but again this is a function of where and how it is used. The Russians, for instance fired thousands of rounds of cluster munitions against Ukrainian population centers such as Kharkiv which was likely a war crime but it would have been whatever weapon was fired. Ukraine has declared that it intends to use the munition only against military targets primarily those defensive lines which are mainly in rural areas which are already surrounded by minefields and probably unexploded ordnance. It becomes trickier if they have to attack Russian defenses in villages and towns but again these are already likely to be heavily contaminated.

The AFU will be using its supplies of DPICM against military targets primarily in open countryside against an enemy who has routinely used Soviet-era cluster munitions and other highly unreliable conventional munitions against civilian targets. We must also not forget this war is being fought on Ukraine’s own territory the AFU is not likely to use a weapon that will cause further unnecessary destruction or unexploded ordnance contamination.

20 comments

  1. Even if they were inhumane, everything should be allowed to eliminate this horde of evil, criminal savages.

    • No more inhumane than phosphorus and thermobarbic bombs that russia use regularly on civilian targets.

      • Killing children is the most inhumane thing to do, and the mafiosi have been doing this all along.

  2. I’m sure if the Ukrainian public were asked to give their opinion on the use of cluster munitions against the orcs, there would be a resounding yes vote. The do gooders can go fuck themselves, their country has not been invaded by subhuman cockroaches.

  3. Here is what Gospodin Trumpkov has to say on his favourite putlerite site about clusters. He puts himself on the same page as the “Human Rights” Marxists and billionaire hippie scum like Ben and Jerry:

    “Dragging Us Further Toward World War III”: Trump Condemns Biden Sending Cluster Bombs to Ukraine:-

    “Dragging Us Further Toward World War III”: Trump Condemns Biden Sending Cluster Bombs to Ukraine

    When a gigantic horde of murder-rape-torture-dismember nazi vermin come on your land, you chuck everything you’ve got at them.

    • Can someone please tell this stinky Trump that we are not afraid of WWIII. To me as a soldier it is just a scenario and even a nuclear war would be of limited impact due to our modern defense technology. So this civilian Trump who never served in the military should GFH!

  4. The description I’ve heard about cluster munitions sounds like the bombing equivalent of artillery grapeshot, or at a much smaller scale, shotgun shells.

    Artillery grapeshot eventually was traded for shrapnel as cannons became fazed out in favor of more efficient howitzers, though I see after a computer search, that even today, shrapnel is still rarely used. I think this is because the more solid shot is much more effective at destroying enemy vehicles, forcing troops to fight on foot, which weakens enemies as they have to spread out.

    But shotguns are still quite commonly used, and I doubt many owners will ever choose to give them up. If a shotgun is “inhumane” to use against a burglar threatening your family or property, then why is the burglar there? If he doesn’t want to face a shotgun wound, then he shouldn’t enter a home without invitation. In a law-abiding society that respects justice, even a criminal doesn’t need to worry about suddenly getting attacked at random. It’s only when a criminal starts a crime, that a victim obviously needs to defend themselves or their family and property.

    The russian military are burglars here, and use far more gruesome methods. If supporters of the invaders complain about the “inhumane” treatment they get, then maybe like a burglar fearing a warning sign of a shotgun, the russians should have stayed out of their neighbor’s “house.”

    • That’s not a good analogy. After the grapeshot or shotgun has been fired, the iron balls/lead pellets don’t pose any risk to people who come across them later. Because the submunitions spread by cluster munition are explosive devices, they can kill or maim civilians who come across them long after the shot was fired.

        • Appreciate the offer, but I’ll pass.

          (Note that I was just explaining why a comparison with grapeshot or shotgun is a bad analogy. I was in no way suggesting that Ukraine shouldn’t be given the cluster munitions.)

      • Larry I think you’re off base and mid infirmed. The Russian cluster bomb shave a misfire of up to 40%. The US cluster bongs have a misfire rate or 2-4%. That’s nothing compared to what is going on. You’re way off base on this one. I advise you to get yurt facts straight before you start pontificating moral outrage.

        • Sir Willie – no moral outrage here; just pointing out facts.

          “a misfire rate or 2-4%” – According to the following article, the cluster munitions that will be sent to Ukraine contain older grenades known to have a failure rate of 14 percent or more.

          And it really doesn’t matter what the misfire rate is, if it’s above zero. That the odds of it happening was only 0.01% is small consolation to the farmer who got a leg blown off, or to the small child who got killed.

          War is hell. Shit happens. Ukraine needs them. But artillery grapeshot fired last month isn’t going to jump out of the ground and hurt someone later on.

          (As I explained to Mike, saying it’s a bad analogy is in no way suggesting that Ukraine shouldn’t be given the cluster munitions.)

          “US cluster bongs” – I think I used one of those back in the 70’s. Is that related to the article about Crimea being sown with medical cannabis ? 🙂

          https://usbongs.weebly.com/

          https://ukrainetoday.org/2023/07/14/after-the-deoccupation-crimea-is-planned-to-be-sown-with-medical-cannabis/

        • I find it odd that my comment is still awaiting moderation, and yet multiple people have already “Liked” it.

          • Strange things happen here sometimes, Larry. I think there are some glitches on WordPress that causes them.

            • Thanks, foccusser. I’ve seen this before when I include multiple links; my guess is that it’s flagged for potential spam.

Enter respectful comments here: