Massive Russian Shortages Hampering Large-Scale Kharkiv Assault: ISW

May 11, 2024

Russian military personnel during the Victory Day parade at Red Square on May 9, 2024, in Moscow, Russia. Moscow doesn’t have enough troops deployed around the northern Ukrainian city of Kharkiv to capture it, according to a defense thinktank. 
 CONTRIBUTOR/GETTY

Russia currently lacks the troops to capture or encircle Ukraine’s second-largest city, Kharkiv, according to the latest report from the Institute for the Study of War, a Washington D.C.-based think tank.

This is despite Russian forces launching a two-pronged attack into Kharkiv Oblast on Friday which the ISW said made “significant tactical gains.”

The Russian military has been advancing gradually over the past few months in Ukraine’s eastern Donbas region, which is partly under Moscow’s control and was formally annexed by Russian President Vladimir Putin in September 2022. Ukraine received a major boost in April when Congress passed a foreign aid package containing an additional $60.84 billion for Kyiv which was held up for months by opposition from Republican hardliners in the House of Representatives.

Friday saw Russian troops launch two limited attacks into Kharkiv Oblast, one to the immediate north of Kharkiv itself and one further east near Vovchansk. However, according to the ISW, fears that Moscow will attempt to seize Kharkiv are likely misplaced and Russian commanders are instead trying to draw Ukrainian troops away from the Donbas and other regions in the east.

The think tank said: “Russian forces are likely conducting the initial phase of an offensive operation north of Kharkiv City that has limited operational objectives but is meant to achieve the strategic effect of drawing Ukrainian manpower and material from other critical sectors of the front in eastern Ukraine…

“ISW continues to assess that Russian forces will likely struggle to seize Kharkiv City should they aim to do so. A Russian effort to seize Kharkiv City would require long drives across open terrain on a scale that Russian forces have not conducted since the start of the full-scale invasion.”

In particular, the ISW noted the Ukrainian Main Military Intelligence Directorate estimates Russia currently has around 35,000 troops stationed on the border of Kharkiv Oblast, substantially less than the roughly 300,000 a Russian opposition news publication suggested would be needed to take the city of Kharkiv.

“Russian opposition outlet Verstka reported in March 2024, citing a Kremlin source, that the Russian military assesses that it needs 300,000 additional personnel (roughly 60 percent of the approximately 510,000 personnel Russian forces currently have in Ukraine) in order to launch an operation to encircle Kharkiv City…

“Ukrainian Main Military Intelligence Directorate (GUR) Deputy Chief Major General Vadym Skibitskyi stated on May 2 that Russian forces have currently concentrated roughly 35,000 personnel in the international border area and plan to concentrate a total of 50,000 to 70,000 personnel in this area.”

Newsweek has reached out to the Russian and Ukrainian ministries of defense for comment by email.

On Thursday, the German government announced it had purchased three American-made M142 High Mobility Artillery Rocket Systems, commonly known as HIMARS, which will be given to Ukraine.

Speaking after a meeting with U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin, German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius said: “In cooperation with the Americans, we will purchase three HIMARS launchers for Ukraine.

“They will come from the U.S. Armed Forces and will be paid for by us.”

Ukraine has been striking back using unmanned drones to hit oil refineries and other targets in Russia and ships from Russia’s Black Sea fleet.

Ukraine’s Main Intelligence Directorate of Ukraine estimated on Friday that its maritime drones have caused $500 million in damage to the Black Sea Fleet during attacks that sunk or damaged a number of vessels.

https://www.newsweek.com/massive-russian-shortages-hampering-large-scale-kharkhiv-assault-isw-1899575

9 comments

  1. The mafia forces might be too weak to take Kharkiv, the development can hardly be seen as a positive one. I hope the defenses are strong enough to stop their advance. The roaches are already too close and are making life hell for the city.
    I wonder what happened to the free Russian forces that entered mafia land.

    • The trumpkov aid block not only caused the needless death of thousands of Ukrainians, it enabled the orc scum to advance.
      How long will it take to push them back to where they were before the intervention of the magaputler shitheads?

        • It was a rhetorical question, to drive home the enormous damage done to Ukraine by the magaputler shitheads.

          • Those who support Donald VonShitzenpantz won’t accept that the orange shitgibbon bears any blame for that.

            • Is VonShitzenpantz what I think it is? 😂 And, orange shit gibbon is also a good one.

              • “VonShitzenpantz” is in the court record.

                https://www.newsweek.com/donald-trump-attorney-court-move-leaves-stunned-1896847

                And “orange shitgibbon” is from a funny story making the rounds. It’s apparently *not* true, but it’s good for a laugh.

                This actually happened and Trump was forced to hear every word from a multitude of Americans.
                Trumps’ Fraud Trial: NYC jury selection Voir Dire:
                “It says here that you tweeted and I quote:
                “Fuck that treasonous orange shitgibbon and the dead ferret on his head.”
                Is that accurate?”
                “The tweet speaks for itself, your honor.”

                • “…dead ferret on his head.”

                  😂🤣🤣😂

                  Thanks for another laugh, Larry!

Leave a Reply to onlyfactspleaseCancel reply