Nonresident fellow hos Centre of Defence Strategies
Mar 22, 2925
To solve a war, you need to understand the root cause
Steve Witkoff, US Special Envoy to the Middle East, unfortunately, has no clue.
In an interview with Tucker Carlson, he made several grossly flawed statements.
Firstly, he said “The so-called four regions: Donbas, Crimea, you know the names, Luhansk and there are two others” are the biggest obstacles to resolving the war started by Russia.” Territorial concession is not the hurdle. It would be a strategic mistake. Russia’s aim of strategic parity with the US and China is the main obstacle.
Secondly, he falsely claims that “They’re Russian speaking, there have been referendums where the overwhelming majority of the people have indicated that they want to be under Russian rule. I think that’s the key issue in the conflict.”
The language does not define anyone’s nationality. The people who used to live in the regions – before Russia’s war of aggression and the start of forceful displacement – voted overwhelmingly in support of Ukrainian independence in 1991. Russia has, however, completely changed the demography. Many have become either refugees or internally displaced. There have been no credible and internationally recognised referendums in the occupied territories since 24 Feb 2022. His statement is either a result of ignorance, disinformation or worse still, an attempt to distort the facts.
Thirdly, he argues “The question is, will the world acknowledge that those are Russian territories? Will it end up? Can Zelenskyy survive politically if he acknowledges this? This is the central issue in the conflict.” This is utter nonsense.
The issue of international recognition of Russian sovereignty over the occupied parts of Ukraine is crucial to international law and the security architecture that has ensured our common security, stability and prosperity since the end of WW2.
Putin sees international recognition of its occupied territories and the lifting of sanctions as a prerequisite for “peace”. Giving in to his demands means undermining international law. It is a signal that “might make right” and serves as an encouragement for other autocracies which consider changing borders with military force. It would not least, ensure that the “peace” will be temporary. Russia will be in a far better position to launch its next assault against Ukraine. It is engaged in an existential war in which it either defeats Ukraine and creates the preconditions for Great Power status or is defeated and remains a pariah state, fully dependent upon China, Iran and North Korea.
This is, therefore, not an issue about Zelenskyy’s political survival. Being the Head of State of a democracy, the decision about territorial concessions is not his to make. The population says no.
It is an issue about Ukraine’s existence. It is a question about international law, global security and stability. It is a question about the imperative of understanding the problem before trying to fix it.
Political cartoon: James Ferguson

……….
Comment from :
Peter Lohmander
The root of the war:
The main interest of Putin is to be at war, all the time. This way, he can control his own population, since everybody is scared and no open opposition can exist.
It does not matter to Putin that Russia makes a huge economic loss because of the war.
Even before the war, Russia was the largest country on Earth, with lots of resources.
With clever management, all people in Russia could have a great standard of living.
The Putin administration is however not interested in creating a good future for the people of Russia.
The Putin administration has one interest: To stay in power. The only method they know is to keep everybody scared. The invention of a (fake) enemy and a ”necessary” war are useful tools.
Because of the war, perhaps Russia gains a small extra territory, destroyed and of low economic value, compared to the very large costs of almost a million killed and wounded Russian soldiers, destroyed battle tanks, destroyed international relations etc.
That is still what we can expect, as long as the Putin administration stays in power
Lasha Amashukeli
“and there are two others” – this shows how “good” his knowledge is in this conflict!
About “referendums”: In Georgia we had 2 this kind of referendums:
1) In Abkhazia 2) So called “South Ossetia”
in Both cases scenario was the same:
First Russia starts to give (force) it’s passports to some separatists in region.
Then provokes military conflicts and fight on side of separatists;
Then Georgian majority population (in both region) flee from conflict zones;
Then under russian militants supervision they organize “referendum” and guess what results those referendum gives?
I can ensure Steve Witkoff, that in his home city in US, if there will be referendum under those circumstances, the result will be: “99.9% voted for being integral part of the Russia!”
Edvin Kornelius
Almost every day, Team Trump reveals shocking news confirming its ties to the Kremlin. I’m starting to wonder if these ties are real or if we’re part of a staged Hollywood blockbuster or one of many episodes of a Netflix series(?)👇
https://www.linkedin.com/posts/kornelius_russianwar-ukraine-europe-activity-7309141258793353216-2RUG
Peter Paul
EDVIN KORNELIUS
Absolutely the Truth. But it seems that MAGA has never been taught basic question high school World History. Our education system has failed us. There are so many Americans who have no idea what our country was fighting against in WWII. Millions of human beings died during WWII. Trump has called the countless American soldiers and sailors that gave their lives fighting exactly what Trump is doing to America now. Trump has said that our war heroes who died for our country “Losers and Suckers”. The MAGA ignorance is astounding.
Adam A. Blanco
The root cause of the war is Putin´s rejection of Ukrainian sovereignty. This can not be solved until Putin and his collection of Soviet-era septuagenarians are out of the Kremlin.
Peter C.
Steve Witkoff’s Russian roots may explain his leaning.
…….
Palle Mathiasen
WORLD WAR 3
JP Morgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon has said that world war 3 has already begun.
The man is right.
World war 3 actually started in 2014 with the Russian invasion of Ukranian Crimea. It is increasing in intensity , especially since the Russian full scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022 – and the October 7 attack on Israel and the ensuing wars.
Vladimir Putin has a Blueprint for world order, where the world is cut up into what he calls a multipolar world, essentially north/south America for the USA, Europe Africa for Russia, and Asia including Taiwan for China.
It is a declaration of war against the American world order after world war 2.
World war 3 is like a fire gaining momentum. It may not become a nuclear war, but it can still be very destructive.
Bombs ready to go off, is Iranian nukes, or joint US Israeli attack on Iran. Chinese invasion of Taiwan. Russian invasion of the Baltic NATO member states, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania – and North Korean agression.
How to stop this fire ? – The US needs to put it down where it started, starting in Ukraine. Russia must not be rewarded, if this happens the fire will spread. Right now Trump seems to add fuel to the fire.
In the picture German foreign minister Annalena Baerbock in a Ukranian command post.
Trump #Putin #China #Russia #Ukraine


I could watch only a small bit of the video. As usual with interviews by Tucker, it almost made me go vomit. Tucker was at his usual worst, and that squeaky voice is already bad enough, but Wittkoff was also a sort of puke bag … the sort you use during a flight. I can’t believe that this prick represents the US as special envoy.
It was, indeed, russian propaganda, and that alone was sickening.