Why Russia blew up the Kakhovka dam

Extract from an article by Charles Moore

From magazine issue:


10 June 2023

Satellite imagery after the damage to the Nova Kakhovka Dam (2023 Maxar Technologies

When I first heard that the Russians had blown up the Kakhovka dam, I assumed that this was an effective tactic to frustrate the Ukrainian counteroffensive. It will surely slow it. But a Ukrainian friend raises an additional possibility – that these are the scorched-earth tactics the Germans used in much the same places 80 years ago. Writing from Kyiv, she quotes a letter from Himmler to the SS commander in Ukraine in September 1943: ‘It is necessary to make sure that when retreating from Ukraine, not a single person, not a single animal, not a single gram of grain, not a single metre of railway track is there, so that not a single house survives… The enemy must be a totally burned and devastated country.’ She thinks Putin’s only tactic is to ‘make Ukraine unliveable in order to force an end to resistance’. This is a shockingly believable thought. The cold comfort in it is that, if the fate of the Nazis is anything to go by, this is the policy of a power facing defeat.

It is a cliché, but true, that the public prefer small charities because they can stay closer to their mission than big ones. A related point is that donors, volunteers etc can get closer too. In Kramatorsk in eastern Ukraine recently, I arrived in a SUV driven (not by or with me) from England and repurposed by the small charity Mission Ukraine as a field ambulance for the wounded at the front. As I got out, I looked closely at the vehicle for the first time. The whole body was painted in battlefield matt-green, and near the right wheel in white was written the name ‘T. Gaisman’. Gosh, I thought, I knew her. Tessa Gaisman was a delightful woman, a former diary secretary for Margaret Thatcher. With Amanda Ponsonby, she saved the notes for the leader’s party conference speech scattered in the drama of the IRA bomb in the Grand Hotel, Brighton, in October 1984. Mrs Thatcher said she was ‘Peace at the heart of the whirlwind.’ Tessa died prematurely last year. It was inspiring and fitting to see her name thus commemorated by her husband Jonathan and now about to go into the whirlwind of war to rescue the wounded.

Proximate peoples often make fiercer enemies than those at a great distance. Anything shared can become a source of contention – a shared language, for example, because one lot pronounces it differently from the other. In Ukraine, I discovered, Russians speaking Ukrainian are always identifiable by their inability to distinguish in their pronunciation between the word for white bread, ‘palyanitsa’, and the word for strawberries, ‘polunytsya’. In the early days of the war, this was used as a way of detecting Russians at checkpoints. I wonder if President Zelensky, originally a Russian speaker, gets that one right. I am told he has continued with Ukrainian lessons, and with English ones, while in office, greatly improving in both tongues.

WRITTEN BY

Charles Moore

Charles Moore is a former editor of The Spectator and the Daily Telegraph. He became a non-affiliated peer in July 2020.

From the same issue of The Speccie is an article by the historian Andrew Roberts:

Andrew Roberts

My hope for Ukraine

•
From magazine issue:
10 June 2023

When Winston Churchill visited bomb sites during the Blitz, the most common sentiment he heard was, ‘We can take it!’, followed closely by ‘Give it ’em back!’. That emotion is very evident in Kyiv, where Ukrainians are understandably nonplussed at opposition in some British newspapers like the Times to their drone attacks on Moscow. They point out that they are attacking military targets there, unlike Russia’s terror attacks on civilians.

I was in Kyiv as part of General David Petraeus’s delegation to a conference organised by the Cipher Brief, a national security-focused media organisation. He and I are publishing a book entitled Conflict: The Evolution of Warfare From 1945 to the Russian Invasion of Ukraine in October, which includes a chapter on the future of war, so it was invaluable to meet special-operations, military-intelligence, cyber-security and army officers. For all that we learnt about the probable future of warfare, however, the banshee wail of sirens is an atavistic sound redolent of its past.

I downloaded the Air Alarm Ukraine app, which proved useful in warning about the nightly air-raids, but despite being attacked by more than 400 Iranian Shahed drones and 114 cruise missiles in the past month, Kyiv is in fact one of the less unsafe cities, as it is superbly protected by the Patriot anti-missile system. An aide to President Zelensky joked that just as celebrities are given lifetime supplies of products they promote, Ukraine should get a lifetime’s supply of Patriot missiles from its manufacturer Raytheon. The attacks on Kyiv have cost Russia $1.7 billion, which Ukrainians point out it can only afford because European countries still buy so much of its oil and gas.

Earlier in the war another kind of patriot shot at drones: Kyiv citizens who went out on to their roofs to take potshots. Policemen would jump out of their cars to fire at drones. Unfortunately, the bullets that missed had to land somewhere, so eventually Kyiv’s charismatic mayor Vitali Klitschko had to ask people to stop doing it. At dinner with Vitali and his younger brother Wladimir, a former heavyweight world champion boxer, they emphasised the huge advantage to the West of admitting an army of 900,000 seasoned veterans into Nato once the war is won. Similarly, the head of Ukraine’s territorial army pointed out that his command is twice the size of the entire British Army (before kindly presenting me with a dagger). If Nato fails to indicate at least a long-term path to future membership at the Vilnius Summit on 11 July, we will be missing a great opportunity, and probably also condemning Ukraine to future Russian aggression.

Visiting Bucha, where 116 Ukrainian civilians were executed (including two children and 30 women) and thrown into a mass grave behind a church, was a sobering experience. Irpin, where similar atrocities took place – as they probably have right across the Russian-occupied areas of Ukraine – still has the famous bridge of wooden planks over which so many refugees crossed to safety. The bridge is being rebuilt, but they ought to keep the planks as a memorial.

Viktor Khorenko, the commander of Ukrainian Special Operations, is a mountain of muscle with eyes like the slits of the pillboxes on the road to Hostomel airport. During our meeting at his HQ, an aide entered to warn of an air-raid. As I put my pen in my pocket and began to collect up my notes prior to getting up and going to the air-raid shelter, I noticed that no one else had moved. ‘Maybe close the drapes?’ was all that Petraeus suggested, but they didn’t even do that. The continual praise for the British government’s initiatives since even before the war started, especially Khorenko’s encomium to the SAS as the only foreign military force that had never left Ukraine since the invasion, made me proud to be British.

Idealistic young Ukrainians hope that when the crucifixion of their country is finally over, the present sense of national unity will allow a new Ukraine to emerge, free of the corruption that had discouraged western investment before the war. They want government infrastructure contracting to be transparent, and are thinking deeply about how to win the peace when it eventually comes. Here’s hoping. Slava Ukraini!

WRITTEN BY

Andrew Roberts

Andrew Roberts sits in the House of Lords as Lord Roberts of Belgravia

2 comments

  1. Very nice to see the obvious affection that both of these distinguished historians have for Ukraine.

    ‘Give it ’em back!’.

    Yes. Tenfold. It is as if a pre-holocaust meeting took place with putler and his generals and the nazi rat said: “they don’t like me and that is not forgivable. Besides, I hate all of them. Your orders are to murder civilians, rape children, torture them, kidnap them, thieve off them, castrate men, behead men, burn women after you raped and tortured them and smash everything to bits. In addition, in case things don’t go well, prepare for ecocide and a massive nuclear incident.
    Tell your men that Ukrainians are nazis and they are free to do whatever they want to them.
    Officers who achieve my rape and torture targets will be doubly rewarded.”

  2. Zel speaking last night (imperfect translation) :

    🇺🇦 Vladimir Zelensky’s address at the end of the 470th day of the war:

    “Today has been a very long and hard day. Kherson and region, Nikolaev наina, cities and communities of our dniprov щиini. Meetings, meetings, evacuation points, international appeal.

    Russian terrorists are trying to exacerbate the situation they caused with their ecocide. Absolutely on the conscious.

    They continue to shelling at Kherson and communities in the area – already flooded by terrorists. They are even firing at evacuation points which is an evil that apparently no terrorist in the world except the Russians have ever visited. The occupants completely threw the nazzvolâ панe people on the left bank part of herson нулиini. For the second day there’s only a catastrophe – and it’s also an absolutely conscious choice of the Russian leadership.

    There are no people in the world now who would not see that Russia is ruled by non-humans. Non-humans who personally are the biggest disaster on the planet today.

    We have to do together with partners everything to prove that the world can deal with such disasters – with such terrorists.

    Офіс Президента України

Enter respectful comments here: