Useless Europe needs Biden to defend Ukraine

Some leaders may roll their eyes, but if the US ceased its support, they could not contain Russia alone.

Tim Stanley

10 July 2023 •

President Joe Biden
President Joe Biden

Joe Biden is in the UK ahead of the Nato summit. No old man jokes, please. I’ve hit that age where I don’t laugh when he falls over, I look on with admiration when he gets back up. No doubt he’ll be greeted with a grand display of unity and hope after the anti-Putin coup attempt, for the Russian invasion of Ukraine has never looked more like reckless folly.

But there are cracks in the Western alliance. Some of us are unhappy about America donating cluster bombs; Germany is reluctant to see Ukraine join Nato. Such rifts underscore the long-term problem of a divided Europe relying on Washington for support that is dangerously contingent upon American politics.

Perhaps because of his age, Biden is the archetypal post-war president. He entered Congress in 1973 opposed to the Vietnam War; since then he has yo-yoed from dove to hawk and back. He opposed Bush Sr’s Gulf War yet endorsed Bush Jr’s great adventure in Iraq, claiming credit for drafting parts of the Patriot Act. Just as the American public turned sour on intervention post-Vietnam, Biden rediscovered his realism after Iraq – privately cautioned against the Libya bombing, even the raid on Osama bin Laden in Pakistan. After the election in 2020, he withdrew from Afghanistan.

Biden won office because he actually has a pretty good grasp of what the American people will tolerate, and the bellwether president has intuited that voters still wish to run the world – but from a safe distance.

Thus Biden has reacted to Ukraine with rhetorical commitment plus a carefully judged amount of arms, providing enough to keep Ukraine in the game, but not quite enough, complains Kyiv, to win (an example: the administration declined to provide F-16s on the grounds that the country “doesn’t need them now”, but former defence secretary Robert Gates argues that had it started training Ukrainian pilots six months ago, F-16s might be making a difference today).

The administration is worried about pushing Putin so far into a corner that he lashes out with nukes, or digs in for as long as he has breath. Hence the latest row over who should replace the outgoing Jens Stoltenberg as secretary general of Nato. Britain wants Ben Wallace for the job, a hawk. But after London announced plans to provide F-16 training – without Washington’s approval – Biden decided to back Ursula von der Leyen, on the presumption, we think, that a less ideological, EU-brand candidate will signal to Putin that an off-ramp remains in place. If Moscow wishes to negotiate, the West is open to it.

Critics say this is naïve. Had Biden approved Wallace instead, it would have told Putin that we’re in this fight for the long haul – so he’d be smarter to withdraw ASAP before he’s removed from office by a rogue chef (I will never get over that Yevgeny Prigozhin was in catering before he ran a private army).

The words “long haul”, however, probably won’t poll well in Iowa and New Hampshire; according to one poll, a third of Americans think the war is already too expensive. Some Republicans complain that Biden is fighting the wrong enemy, that the US is depleting expensive weapons stocks at the moment when China is on the rise. They have a point. Last year, the administration said use of cluster-bombs could be a war crime; Biden has decided now to gift some of those vile weapons to Zelensky because not only is Ukraine running low on regular ammunition, so is the US.

Biden, though his instincts are populist, is currently very unpopular – and will face Ron DeSantis or Donald Trump in next year’s election, both of whom are war-sceptics. Trump has pledged to end it within 24 hours, raising the question of what Europe will do if Washington’s support for Ukraine dries up because the GOP wins or the Democrats lose their nerve.

Defence spending in central and west European states has increased: it has jumped 30 per cent on a decade ago and is now higher than the last year of the Cold War. Finland has joined Nato and Sweden has applied for membership. The EU has sent arms and the Continent is committed to energy security. Ukraine has changed our corner of the planet radically and quickly. Yet Germany did itself reputational damage by dragging its feet over supplying tanks and France looks foolish for pursuing a diplomatic solution long after it was credible. Moral weight has shifted eastwards, where countries, such as summit host Lithuania, are far more likely to hit their Nato target of spending 2 per cent of GDP on defence.

In short, the Continent is not unified or spending enough to imagine it could contain Russia alone – and it would be alone because the developing world is neutral (at best). Meanwhile, the Ukrainians fight bravely but their offensive hasn’t broken through spectacularly yet, and there are signs that the Russians are better playing defence than offence.

One interpretation of the conflict is that it isn’t the return of power-bloc competition – as in the Cold War – but a rogue nation-state testing if it can act independently and in defiance of the US. Such independence of action is precisely what Europe does not have because we lack the arms and, for all the EU’s pretence to sovereignty, do not think and act like a coherent civilisation. When the emperor of the new Rome comes visiting, we’d better play nice: we rely upon America for our protection, arguably for our very survival.

4 comments

  1. Selected comments from DT readers:

    Phil Jarrett:
    “When it comes to the crunch American self interest will trump every other consideration in the end. America will ultimately seek an end to hostilities in Ukraine where both sides can save face and some kind of buffer zone is established between Russia and Ukraine with neither side having a military advantage (for now). Ukraine will not join NATO but be given security assurances in case it’s attacked.”

    Andrew Fairfoull:
    “It doesn’t matter how much ammunition or weapons you send to Ukraine, the Ukrainians will never defeat Russia. That’s a plain fact, all more arms will do is ensure more and more brave Ukrainians are killed on the battlefield. I blame the US, EU and the UK for making a bad situation even worse. NATO are meeting this week, and the 1 country that they should be talking to is Russia to try to end this dreadful conflict ASAP.”

    A couple of replies to this glib fart-arse :

    John Mulvany:
    Reply to Andrew Fairfoull :
    “Russia has already lost, just depends on how long it takes them to “ get it”

    Stuart Myhill:
    Reply to Andrew Fairfoull:
    “Duh!! This invasion was preceded by a procession of western emissaries trying to dissuade Putin.”

    UK Scientist
    “The nonsense of Brussels claiming to represent ‘Europe’ could not be more clearly demonstrated by the schism between Western Europe which is indeed ‘useless’ and Eastern Europe which with limited resources is doing all it can to help Ukraine (with the exception of Hungary). It is incredible that Biden is thinking of handing NATO to the control of Brussels.”

  2. “Such independence of action is precisely what Europe does not have because we lack the arms and, for all the EU’s pretence to sovereignty, do not think and act like a coherent civilisation. When the emperor of the new Rome comes visiting, we’d better play nice: we rely upon America for our protection, arguably for our very survival.”

    That’s a sad commentary for a civilization that has seen and been in the middle of atrocities that have shaken it’s very foundations but were able to rally and come together to restore freedom and independence. WTF HAPPENED TO THE EUROPE I THOUGHT I KNEW. Europeans or Ethan’s more to the point, the European leaders of today have turned into complete self serving wimps without an iota of shame. Europe, your ancestors are rolling in their graves with pure disgust

    • Europe has become a collection of lazy slobs, who are used to having the United States cover their fat asses. Eastern Europe, however, is not asleep at the wheel. They know very well what’s at stake.

  3. “When the emperor of the new Rome comes visiting, we’d better play nice: we rely upon America for our protection, arguably for our very survival.”

    Europe’s star is sinking. It’s already close to the horizon. And yet, most are still dreaming of times gone by.

Enter respectful comments here: