Ukraine’s dam explosion is a red line: Russia must feel the consequences

If the Kremlin is prepared to create havoc on such a scale, then it is capable of further escalation

. June 9

Ukrainian servicemen evacuate flood victims around Kherson. Any acceptance of this humanitarian, economic and environmental atrocity merely invites Moscow to go one step further © Genya Savilov/AFP/Getty Images

The writer is former Deputy Supreme Allied Commander Europe and author of ‘War with Russia’ Truly, the horsemen of the apocalypse have descended upon Ukraine. With the Kakhovka dam breach, Russia has seemingly added a grotesque act of environmental terrorism to brutal occupation, the continuing loss of a generation of young Ukrainian men and women in combat, the massacre of civilians and the destruction of cities on a scale not seen in Europe since 1945.

The immediate priority is international humanitarian support. But thus far, the response appears to have come under the ‘too difficult’ heading. Coming, as it does, in the early stages of Ukraine’s counter offensive, the flood will be a major distraction at a time when every heart, nerve and sinew is being strained to achieve a decisive victory. The relief effort will suck up resources Ukraine can ill-afford to spare, not least in the face of relentless Russian bombardment of rescue efforts in Kherson. That said, the flood presents opportunities for Ukraine. Open source reports indicate the destruction of heavy equipment and flooding of Russian defences and minefields on the east bank of the Dnipro. Water supplies to Crimea are severely affected, with implications for Moscow’s garrison and capabilities there. The flood will also be a distraction for Russia at a time when it is facing multiple probing attacks on different axes along its lengthy front line. The Ukrainians had probably already ruled out an amphibious assault crossing of the southern Dnipro against well-defended Russian positions on the east bank. Kyiv retains the initiative, having just launched its offensive with multiple combined arms attacks, including main battle tanks, against Moscow’s troops. It will continue to probe, identify weaknesses, launch raids and conduct deception operations so that when it concentrates force to attack, it does so against Russian weakness. Ukraine was quick to accuse Russia of blowing up the dam from the inside, though its western allies have not yet committed themselves on the cause of the disaster. The danger is that if the Kremlin is prepared to create havoc on such a scale, then it is capable of further escalation: destruction of the Kyiv dam or the Zaporizhzhia nuclear power plant, the latter potentially resulting in a catastrophic radioactive leak with widespread environmental consequences. From here, the detonation of a tactical nuclear device is not implausible.

The strategic issue, not just for Ukraine’s partners in the west and Nato but for the global community, is to make Russia feel the consequences. Any acceptance of this humanitarian, economic and environmental atrocity merely invites Moscow to go one step further. A red line must be drawn. Ukraine’s partners must take the gloves off and ensure Kyiv has the means to really hurt Russia, for example by targeting the Kerch bridge or the Black Sea fleet in Sevastopol harbour. Following the British lead by supplying more longer-range missiles, such as US ATACMS, and speeding up the deployment of F-16 fighter jets, would be a start. Russia should be suspended from the UN General Assembly, as South Africa was in 1974. As for China and Russia’s tacit supporters in the global south, such as India, South Africa and Brazil, it is time to recognise that fence-sitting while war crimes are being committed is tantamount to being an accessory to the crime. Moscow only recognises strength and where it finds weakness it will continue to exploit it. As the head of Ukraine’s foreign intelligence service told me and others in Kyiv at the end of April, the only way to influence Russia is to hit it in the face — and then talk. This means Nato must demonstrate real strength at its Vilnius summit in July, and produce more than another rhetorical expression of support for Ukraine. Instead, alliance leaders must drive forward a Nato defence and deterrence posture that underscores Nato’s resolve to support Ukraine and begins the process of integrating Kyiv within the transatlantic community, including as a member of the alliance. Ukraine’s war aims must be endorsed in their entirety. The provision of military equipment, ammunition, training and support must become an alliance strategy rather than a bilateral arrangement between individual Nato members and Ukraine. Above all, a fast-track pathway to Ukraine’s membership of the alliance at next year’s Nato summit in Washington must be laid out.

This war is not only against Ukraine, but also against the west and Ukraine joining the west. Even when Kyiv has achieved its military objectives (which, with the full-blooded support of its allies, it can do), Russia will remain an angry, humiliated, traumatised, revanchist state determined to eliminate Ukraine and rebuild another Russian empire. The only way to keep Europe free of war for generations to come is for Nato to establish a line of deterrent steel around its eastern frontier, with Ukraine, Moldova and Georgia and, perhaps one day Belarus, inside. This means the alliance needs to be prepared for the worst case: war with Russia. The long-term implications will be profound.

………….

Comment from the LinkedIn page of Filip Petersson:-

Russia crossed the red line when they blew up the dam. The gloves should come off now and good should take the initiative from evil. Give Ukraine what they want and start mobilizing to back them up. The Russia we are seeing today is simply not compatible with modern civilization. It needs to defeated and pacified, co-existence with these barbarians is simply off the table. Looking at history it has been obvious for a long time, let’s not repeat the mistakes to again.

…………

Dominic Lawson hosts Ukrainian refugees. Here is his reflection of what they say to him about this catastrophe:

DOMINIC LAWSON: I had never seen our Ukrainian guests as upset as they were after the dam blast. They fear their country may be changed for ever.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/debate/article-12183677/DOMINIC-LAWSON-never-seen-Ukrainian-guests-upset-dam-blast.html

8 comments

  1. Decisions need to be made now. We already know that the Nato conference next month will achieve nothing whatsoever that can stop Russian savagery and evil.
    Ukraine’s top three supporters: the US, UK and Poland must act independently of the useless Nato. All three must commit to a quick end to this war. Any additional countries wishing to join the coalition should do so.
    We know it takes weeks or even months to move troops into position, so they should start now.
    Coalition troops to Lviv, Kyiv, Odesa, Mykolaiv. Turn those cities into fortresses so that Ukrainian troops can move to the front line.
    Provide air and sea support.
    Send more MBT’s, artillery, HIMARS.
    Send ATACMS, more Storm Shadows, plus long range air to air missiles.
    Inform putler that those ground troops will not attack unless attacked.
    Also make it clear that the Kakhovka catastrophe is regarded as a WMD event and a colossal war crime committed by the RF and that any further WMD-level events will result in a conventional attack on its occupier forces that will decimate them.

  2. The West shares much fault for the excessive killings and destruction in Ukraine with its false sense of hope on diplomacy early on and subsequent painfully slow approval of weapon systems, painfully slow implementation of sending them, and painfully few. It also has not, by far, achieved the desired results with its sanctions’ regime. We are approaching 16 months of terrible warfare and not a single jet is in the country, nor a single ATACM. Mafia land also is still playing cat and mouse games with grain shipments, since the most powerful nation on earth with the most powerful navy on earth still prefers sitting on the fence to watch. The destruction of the dam has left a lot to be desired in terms of international response. The world by and large has learned exactly nothing in how to handle an evil, rogue, criminal nation as mafia land.

    • This war could be over with today if Biden had the balls. There is a huge air drill going on in Europe with 250 planes, send them to Ukraine, they would devastate the orcs in no time, then just deny everything.

      • Exactly. Instead of showing off our military might we should use it to support Ukraine. Why Nato keeps chickening out against a military dwarf like RuSSia is beyond me. One day some angry ukrainian mamas will visit Washington and the Nato HQ and demand some answers.

        • “Why Nato keeps chickening out against a military dwarf like RuSSia is beyond me.”

          Russia has more nukes than anyone else in the world. I’m pretty sure that’s why. You may agree or disagree with whether that should constrain NATO / the West, but I think it’s pretty clear what’s holding us back.

          • ‘More’ nukes? We only need to deploy a few dozen and RuSSia is history. So in this game dead, more dead or totally dead makes no difference. The day Moscow launches the first nuke they will be gone, their hundred more nukes won’t fall into weight.

      • I’m afraid that we’ll never see such courage in our lifetimes, foccusser. We are damned to live being government by pussies.

Enter respectful comments here: