Nonresident fellow hos Centre of Defence Strategies
- Centre of Defence Strategies
- The Norwegian National Defence College
Norway Contact info
June 11, 2025
It is time to end wishful thinking
For decades, we hoped Russia would turn into a partner, failing to see the resurrection as an aggressive, imperial power happening in front of our very eyes. For three decades, we downsized and streamlined Europe’s warfighting capabilities, hoping that NATO, the rule-based world order, globalisation and mutual dependency would make future wars impossible. We hoped that NATO would deter China, Russia, Iran and North Korea despite our failure to invest in security and defence. We hoped that a strong economy and political wishful thinking would translate into military power and deterrence without investing in the hardware.
This has landed us in the following strategic realities:
A. “We are very sure, and we have intelligence evidence to back this up, that [Russia’s full-scale invasion of] Ukraine is only one step on Russia’s path towards the west.” Russia seeks to “push NATO back to its 1990s boundaries”, “kick out” the US from Europe and “expand its influence by any means necessary”. (Bruno Kahl, Head of Germany’s Federal Intelligence Service, 10 Jun 2025)
B. “Russia could be ready to use military force against NATO within five years. Russia has teamed up with China, North Korea and Iran. They are expanding their militaries and their capabilities. Putin’s war machine is speeding up, not slowing down. Russia is reconstituting its forces with Chinese technology and producing more weapons faster than we thought.” (NATO Sec.Gen Mark Rutte, 9 Jun 2025)
C. Russia will be “capable of a large-scale conventional attack, even on NATO territory, by 2029”. Putin’s goal is to “weaken and destroy NATO as an alliance and discredit our Western form of society”. (Bundeswehr Inspector General Carsten Breuer, 12 Ap 2025)
D. “Although Russia is currently unable to attack another country because of the war in Ukraine, preparations must be made for possible aggression by 2030. But if Ukraine is forced to capitulate – if, for example, Russia takes over Ukraine’s industrial and human resources, the Ukrainian army – the largest army on our side in Europe – then this calculation would change. We must prepare for aggression by the end of the decade.” (Polish Foreign Minister Radoslaw Sikorski, 24 Mar 2025)
E. “Ukraine is fighting for Europe, and Europe needs to stand with those who are fighting for our security and our values. The security of Ukraine is the security of Europe.” (President of the EU Parliament Roberta Metsola, 6 March 2025)
For 11 years, we have hoped to reestablish peace in Europe by promising Putin what he wants. We have hoped for the power of diplomacy. It is time to end wishful thinking. Words will not deter Russia. It is not seeking peace. Russia is seeking strategic parity with the US and China at the cost of Europe. We must either defend ourselves in Ukraine today or wait until the enemy is at our gates. We can no longer base our collective security on the hope of US support.
Political cartoon: Ingram Pinn

Comment from :
Georg Barth
By this knowings the future of NATO and Europe is not at all safe!
Georg Barth, that is correct. I have only presented the latest of a long list of Heads of State, Ministers of Defence, Chiefs of Defence and Heads of Intelligence warning the West that NATO might be in open conflict with Russia within 3-5 years. This is why I find the term “Russia Ukraine War” extremely misleading.
Hans Petter Midttun I find extremely misleading “3-5 years”. The bear checked Europe for reaction multiple times, and find Europe really attractive… Endless discussions, rampant corruption, absolutely desoriented and personal comfort obssessed population, fragmented societies with unloyal diasporas… Just dream land for aggressor.
Anatoliy Yefymenko, just to make sure I understand you correctly: Russia has been waging a hybrid war against the EU and it’s member states for years already. It’s aggressions have escalated the last years as a result of lack of response from NATO (which has not yet acknowledged Russia’s hostile acts as a part of a broader confrontation). In this context 3-5 years might come across as strange. The timeline refers, however, to the assumption that an ongoing hybrid war might turn into a conventional war within 2030.
Hans Petter Midttun I think Putin has no this 3-5 years. He put everything on war (Army. economy, political system). If he stops abroutly he could have riots in the army, unrest with workers and risk of loosing power. Putin also could be motivated for quicker actions with uncertainty in two key elements of success – for how long Trump will stay in power (Trump as a guarantoor US will not join conflict in Europe), and how long will take Europeans rearmament and their getting the right mood for fighting (that is nobody could estimate the key problem is Europeans are not ready to fight for their prosperity and democracy). It should be clear, Russian Army consist of 2 parts. Valuable specialists (technical and command) and cheap “cannon fodder” (for meat waves). The quolity of “cannon fodder” doesn’t metter (almost any level of health, training, motivation or even loyalty). “Meat” is simply fuel to keep steamroller move.
Anatoliy Yefymenko, I don’t disagree with your opinion. Europe is historically weak and the longer the Kremlin waits, the stronger Europe will become. The rearmament process has started. That said, Russia is struggling against Ukraine. According to several agencies, including the Foreign Intelligence of Ukrainian, Russia will need 2-4 years to rearm before it can continue westward. If sanctions are lifted, this time will be shorter.
POSTSCRIPT:
At a time when the very future of Europe and the post-war liberal democratic order hangs in the balance, European political leaders can no longer afford to indulge in prevarications. Western Europe writ large is already in the Russian Federation’s cross hairs. Sadly, it’s still far from clear the Trump Administration can be relied upon to honor America’s longstanding security commitments to the continent.
Europe is at a crossroads. This is the moment for member countries of the EU and NATO to step up their respective games. It’s time to end the hand-wringing over the necessity for increased defense spending. After three years of unrestricted warfare, it is Ukraine and her people which have disproportionately borne the burdens of war and demonstrated their mettle. Despite every obstacle, she is holding fast all along the frontlines and against all odds while actively degrading the invader’s offensive capabilities.
It’s time for Europe to double down on its commitment to enabling the decisive defeat of the Russian Federation’s forces in Ukraine. Only the speedy and conclusive defeat of Russia’s armed forces in Ukraine will lead to a just and equitable peace and a brighter future for Europe and the world.
