
Negotiations to end the war in Ukraine may begin in early 2025. But what happens if the Russian President refuses a ceasefire?
24 December 2024
In the final working week before Christmas, EU leaders gathered for a meeting that might prove historic – but not for the reasons they hoped.
Led by Kaja Kallas – the former Estonian PM and now the hawkish head of the EU’s Foreign Policy and Security – the leaders reaffirmed their support for Kyiv. Council President António Costa declared that “Ukraine alone can determine peace terms,” while Commission President Ursula von der Leyen emphasised the need to back President Zelensky, hinting at progress in Ukraine’s EU accession bid.
Yet what made the summit historic wasn’t the unity expressed – it was the cracks that quickly followed.
“Within the EU, you don’t have a consensus, and if you don’t have a consensus, you cannot act in the name of the European Council,” thundered Hungarian Prime Minister Viktor Orbán, long a thorn in the side of attempts to forge a coherent European stance on Russia.
Adding to the unease, von der Leyen admitted, “We also need to know more regarding the plans of the next US administration at the EU’s level.”
And here lies the crux of the matter. Despite over a year of warnings that a Trump presidency was a real possibility, Europe has failed to craft a robust, independent strategy in 2024 less reliant on the US. Now, Europe’s fate – and that of Ukraine – remains tied to the goodwill of an ally that may soon prove unreliable.
Historians may well look back on this meeting, therefore, as Europe’s admission that it’s left itself no choice but to seek a festive miracle from across the Atlantic, hoping that Donald Trump will soon carve out a favourable peace deal with Vladimir Putin.
But all of this is predicated on one massive assumption – that Russia will meaningfully come to the negotiating table in early 2025. What no one seems to be asking is: what if they don’t?
Given the battlefield dynamics and Moscow’s objectives, many convincingly argue that Putin will continue waging war for as long as his economy allows him to. The Kremlin may posture as conciliatory in January, claiming openness to meaningful talks, but what if its proposals are unacceptable to Ukraine and its allies?
This is a crucial question that seems to be almost entirely ignored in Europe. For America, the choice might be easy: pull out. What then for a Europe which has failed to prepare adequately for that scenario, and yet cannot let Kyiv fall?
Reflecting on this impasse, I’m reminded of Woodrow Wilson’s 1917 plea: “Only a tranquil Europe can be a stable Europe. There must be, not a balance of power, but a community of power; not organised rivalries, but an organised common peace.” While Wilson’s League of Nations failed, his belief in higher values over raw power outlived it, especially after the creation of the UN at the end of the Second World War. Yet today, many in the West seem to have abandoned these principles, instead adopting the language of raw strength – “balance of power” and “spheres of influence” being terms we hear all too often.
Such notions cede moral ground to authoritarian regimes, enabling them to claim legitimacy where they have none. Rejecting the principle that a people have the right to determine their own future is tantamount to abandoning democracy itself. Yet many do it when they argue that “Nato expanded too close to Russia – Putin has a right to be upset.” Ukraine, at the ballot box, sought a future closer to Europe and away from its former imperialist overlords. Putin had no right to intervene by force unless you are happy being governed by the rules of the nineteenth century.
I mention this because – morally – the West should not be pursuing negotiations; it should be pursuing Russia’s defeat. The failure to do so reflects a dangerous acquiescence built on flawed ideas.
Even if talks proceed, the outcomes could be bleak indeed. Russia might refuse negotiations outright, leaving Europe unprepared to arm Ukraine independently, while Trump withholds support. Alternatively, Putin could feign good faith, dragging out negotiations while the war continues, only to offer a terrible deal: cede territory with no meaningful security guarantees that Ukraine or Europe could possibly accept.
Recent geopolitical shifts – most notably the collapse of one of the Middle East’s most brutal regimes – have emboldened those who argue that dictatorships appear strong until they suddenly crumble. The implications of that are indeed significant, especially with Donald Trump poised to return to the White House: a man who backs winners. Russia’s recent defeats may lead him to view Moscow as a liability, especially if its economy enters freefall, as some predict. Already the ruble is faltering, basic goods are becoming prohibitively expensive, and defence spending is soaring. It cannot last. But might it last long enough?
The best case scenario is that if Russia refuses to negotiate seriously, the narrative may shift, exposing Moscow – not Kyiv – as the primary obstacle to peace. That could be the moment Washington decides to double down on supporting Ukraine, strengthening its leverage on the battlefield and potentially compelling Moscow to negotiate in earnest.
But this is the most optimistic scenario – and even it entails a longer, bloodier war. This is why it has proven so disastrous for Europe not to demonstrate its capacity – both in moral terms and military terms – to support Ukraine not only to fight, but to potentially win decisively.
When you concede arguments, you ultimately end up conceding territory. That is the price of inaction. And innocent people die.
Francis Dearnley is one of the hosts of our award-winning podcast, Ukraine: The Latest

“morally – the West should not be pursuing negotiations; it should be pursuing Russia’s defeat.”
That is the ONLY honourable opinion available.
Captain Cornflake wants to pursue the very smelly “land for peace” option.
I don’t, but in the event that the majority of Ukrainians do, then I will support them fully.
Only those with crystal balls are talking about “land for peace.” On the other hand, the new upcoming US president has been pursuing a ceasefire as the first step. He also said something, usually ignored by those wielding crystal balls, that if Vladolf doesn’t come to the table, he will arm the shit out of Ukraine. Likely the same thing will happen when Vladolf lies. This is why Zelensky and many others that wield common sense instead of crystals balls, aren’t worried about the new upcoming US president. Hopefully that logic will eventually sink in for those trying to wield crystal balls that have been wrong at every turn.
You obviously did not read what Captain Cornflake wrote. I did, so I do know what is coming. It’s already been committed to paper by him and also your favourite assholes DT Jr, Kennedy, Vance and Musk. It all stinks of kremkrapp.
Unless there is a 180° policy turn, we are in for an outcome that favours putler, not Ukraine.
What do you think Trump means by a “deal?”
Even your hopelessly Trump-addled brain should have deduced by now that there can be no justice for Ukraine in a ceasefire, a “frozen conflict” or any “land for peace” bullshit.
The only solution is the complete destruction of the occupier forces, the restoration of Ukraine’s legal borders and a DMZ on the putinaZi side of those borders.
You can insult all you like but it won’t take away the fact that you don’t know what is going to happen or have any idea of what a deal is. You probably haven’t even considered part of a deal could be sanctions removal. Nope. You just fantasize about your favorite boogey man. He controls you more than me, I can promise you that, lmao…………
I spent Christmas day with a Ukrainian family from Donetsk and we talked for 4 hours and nobody even brought up Trump. They don’t worry about him…but YOU do. Strange.
Comment from :
Phil Dawes
I hope Trump and the people around him choose to back Ukraine fully. That would convince me that Trump is indeed a force for good. The problem is that this would go against his base and his election promises. I hope I am wrong, but my bet is that Trump will try and force Ukraine to cede all of the land taken by Russia. This will put Ukraine in a difficult position in the long run, as Russia will control much of the Black Sea access and be in a position to directly threaten Ukraine in future.
paul atkinson
Who would believe putins acceptance of any peace deal?
he would use it to rebuild his military and strike again when rebuilt
our best hope of peace would be to surround russia in ever tightening sanctions , impose secondary sanctions on india china etc if they continue to support russia.
andrew richards
If Putin gains territory from the negotiations then it will be a repeat of his successful Crimea invasion sending a clear message internationally. Attacking neighbours and inflicting mass murder etc pays.
Paul Rolink
Trump will come down on the side of Ukraine if Russia refuses to negotiate. Not necessarily by being involved in the fighting just arming them sufficiently. The alternative can’t happen as Trump wouldn’t let Russia win the war. Trump negotiates, it’s what he does. European countries would have to fall into line in that case.
I totally agree with the following poster who has a resounding name:
Jennifer Churchill
Russia under Putin deserves nothing at all. Every inch of Ukrainian territory Putin has invaded must be returned to Ukraine. Anything less is unacceptable.
Jonathan Karmi
We’re at the beginning of a dark era. Freedom, democracy and sovereignty can only exist if people are willing to defend them. We are cursed with too many weak or deluded leaders who fail to see that.
Douglas MacDonald
European countries that are closest to Russia and Ukraine are the biggest supporters of European security. Finland,Sweden, and Poland have the biggest and most effective defence capabilities already in place. Denmark is also one of the biggest supporters of Ukraine in terms of supplies of military equipment. These countries are already having talks about forming a seperate European alliance for defence. Europe can no longer rely on NATO alone and their unreliable US aly.
Robert H Smith
Wishful thinking but I really hope you are right Francis. Surely Trump would totally tarnish his reputation and his historical memory by capitulating to the autocratic murderous psychopath Putin let alone the lessons that China would learn from such appeasement?
Toyota Crown
Putin had no right to intervene by force unless you are happy being governed by the rules of the nineteenth century.
I mention this because – morally – the West should not be pursuing negotiations; it should be pursuing Russia’s defeat. The failure to do so reflects a dangerous acquiescence built on flawed ideas.
“When you concede arguments, you ultimately end up conceding territory. That is the price of inaction. And innocent people die.”
Very true. Thank you Francis.