The woman on Putin’s most-wanted list, Estonia’s Kaja Kallas

The Estonian PM has become a star at international summits, but Kaja Kallas’s forthright warnings about the need to stand up to Russia have made her a target of the Kremlin’s fury

Kaja Kallas, 47, and, left, meeting Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky in January
Kaja Kallas, 47, and, left, meeting Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky in JanuaryALAMY, KRÕÕT TARKMEEL/ANNE & STIIL MAGAZINE

Edward Lucas

Friday June 21 2024

Kaja Kallas is in demand. The Estonian prime minister’s international profile belies her country’s size (population: 1.3 million; land area: a bit larger than Switzerland). Winning prizes, storming through summits, she relentlessly makes a simple, existential case: stand up to Russia now or it will be worse later.

Russia’s onslaught on Ukraine has vindicated her warnings and fuelled a stellar career. Her country’s first woman prime minister (she took office in 2021), she is tipped for a top job in Brussels in the carve-up following the latest elections to the European parliament.

• Russia could threaten Nato within three years, says Estonia

With Ursula von der Leyen of the centre-right European People’s Party (EPP) all set to stay in charge of the Commission, Antonio Costa (socialist, former Portuguese PM) becoming head of the European Council, and Malta’s Roberta Metsola (also EPP) continuing as European parliament boss, Kallas, whose Reform party is the main liberal force in Estonia, is already pencilled in for the top diplomatic job: the high representative for foreign affairs and security policy. Crucially, she appears to have won the support of French president Emmanuel Macron.

Kallas is battling not only the Kremlin and political rivals, but also prejudice. Lingering Soviet-era sexism at home leads to sneering press coverage; she blames that on the predominance of “older men” in Estonia’s political press corps.

Abroad, foreigners are wowed by her, busting outdated stereotypes of “east European” politicians as jowly, besuited men with laboured English. Fans abound. One talks of her “political pheromones”; another western policymaker calls her “the hottest date in Europe”. Timothy Garton Ash, the Oxford University historian, praises her “Churchillian” virtues of “courage, resolution and clarity”.

But Kallas, 47, is wanted in another sense. Russia has started criminal proceedings against her transferring Russia’s frozen assets to Ukraine — the only head of government to be treated this way. In the Kremlin’s clutches, she would die in prison.

Estonia’s history adds grim context. Portraits of Kallas’s eight predecessors hang in her office overlooking Tallinn’s medieval old town. Five died at Soviet hands, in captivity or executed, and one shot himself to avoid interrogation. After snuffing out independence in 1940, the Soviet occupiers targeted tens of thousands of people whose only crime was good education or professional success.

Kallas’s grandfather, grandmother and great-grandmother were among them. “My mother was just six months old at the time, and there was little hope of survival,” Kallas recalled in an anniversary speech. “The people in the cattle wagon dried the baby’s diapers on their bodies because it was the only warm and dry place.” Caught between Hitler and Stalin, Estonia lost one fifth of its population. The Soviets made every effort to destroy the country’s identity, dumping hundreds of thousands of Russian-speaking migrants into the towns, destroying monuments and imposing Russian as the language of public life.

Estonians are famously reserved people (in 30-plus years living and visiting there, I have been invited to perhaps five homes). But memories of Soviet repression mean they quiver in sympathy at Ukraine’s agony. Putin’s goal is something that they escaped only narrowly themselves: the annihilation of a nation’s political, cultural and linguistic independence and identity. And, as Kallas says repeatedly, if aggression is rewarded, it will continue.

It is against this backdrop that Kallas walks her tightrope, promoting her country as one of the post-communist success stories, while urging allies to do more to counter the threat from Russia. Overdo the gloom, and business confidence shrivels and investors will flee. Allow complacency to persist, and Russia will exploit it.

Kallas’s effectiveness is based on self-confidence, coupled with a command of history. “The mistake we made in 1938 and 1939 was to treat events in isolation,” she says, citing Italy’s attack on Abyssinia, Japan’s war in China and Germany’s seizure of the Sudetenland. “If aggression pays off somewhere, it happens elsewhere.”

She exemplifies a new generation of east European leaders: unscarred by communism, while remembering enough to be revulsed by any whiff of the past. Kallas recalls a visit to East Berlin in 1988. Her father took his wife and two children to the Brandenburg Gate and told them to breathe deeply of the “air of freedom” that came from West Berlin.

Now freedom reigns, but not yet respect. In the contest to find a European politician to be Nato’s next secretary-general, the word was that a woman, and one from the “new” member states, should break the mould. Kallas fitted the bill. But the Dutch prime minister, Mark Rutte, got the job. “The big ones decided,” says Kallas coolly. The Dutch politician Frans Timmermans dismissed Kallas’s candidacy, implying that someone from a country “next to Russia” would be provocative. Yet the current holder, Jens Stoltenberg, is Norwegian — his country’s border with Russia was first defined in 1826. All European countries are equal, but some are more equal than others.

Now Kallas is in the running again. She is coy when it comes to discussing her lightly concealed ambitions. “Would I like it? I’d like an ice cream. The decision is not in our hands. But it would be a great honour to be considered.”

I catch up with Kallas at Estonia’s annual security conference, where she steals the show in opening and closing sessions. Few westerners know the country better than me. I ran a newspaper in Tallinn in the Nineties. My eldest son was born there, the country’s first “Nato baby”. I remember Kallas’s father, Siim, as finance minister, introducing the new kroon in 1992, replacing the hated “occupation rouble”. Kaja was 15.

Estonia has since become a byword for modernity and economic success. It stars in league tables for internet freedom, transparency and the rule of law.

I have witnessed Estonia’s warnings about the danger from Russia fall on deaf ears. “It is not polite to say, ‘I told you so,’ ” Kallas says drily. Estonia, she notes, rushed weapons to Ukraine before Russia’s onslaught. “If others had done the same, there’d be no war.”

Estonia has already put 1.3 per cent of GDP [about £425 million] into helping Ukraine, more than any other country in Europe relative to its population and economy. It has also pledged 0.25 per of its GDP from 2024-27 as military aid. “If all countries did the same, it would lead to Ukrainian victory,” she says. “Ukraine is losing lives — the only thing they ask of us is reallocation of resources… Promises do not save lives. Air defence does.”

Estonia has passed a law transferring Russia’s frozen assets to Ukraine. Others should do the same, Kallas says. Why should western taxpayers pay for Ukraine’s reconstruction when Russia did the damage, she asks. She lambasts the idea that the way to end the war is with a negotiated settlement, in which Russia gains some Ukrainian territory in return for peace. Kallas will have none of that. Too many think, “Let Russians have what they want and things will settle down,” she says. Far from it. “Ukrainian defeat tells the world aggression pays off. You can colonise another country and nothing happens.”

Estonia also spends heavily on its own defence. But not enough to pay for the air-defence systems, warplanes and other equipment needed for full security. Like its Baltic neighbours Latvia and Lithuania, Estonia hosts tripwire forces from larger countries. But these contingents are for deterrence, not defence. The British armoured deployment in Estonia, for instance, lacks the air defences needed for combat. Most member states have yet to provide the forces required by Nato’s new defence plans. And the prospect of a Trump presidency casts even bigger doubts on future security.

Plugging the gap is costly. The country’s military wants an extra €1.5 billion (£1.25 billion) for ammunition, giving Estonia the chance to use new US-made artillery to strike up to 125 miles inside Russia. Government dithering on this has prompted a sharp political row and the resignation of the defence ministry’s top official.

Kallas’s hawkish line contrasts sharply with the rhetoric from the Biden White House or Olaf Scholz’s Federal Chancellery in Berlin. Western leaders tend to say that they will support Ukraine “for as long as it takes”, without specifying the “it”. Kallas wants the war to end, but with defeat for Putin. More than that: Russia must be “held accountable for what it has done”.

Most western leaders find the idea of forcing Russia to pay reparations not just impractical but worrying. The Putin regime could become more aggressive, reaching for its nuclear arsenal. Or the country could break up, leading to chaos, civil war and refugees. Kallas brushes such fears aside. It is the prospect of Russian victory that is really worrying, she says.

Kallas stresses that Russian aggression already reaches the west. “Our adversary knows that migration is our vulnerability,” she says. “Push migrants to the border, create a problem and then say, ‘It’s human rights. You have to accept them.’ ” Baltic spooks are on alert for a new wave of this. But right now, they and colleagues across Europe are alarmed by a Kremlin tactic: hiring local hooligans to carry out acts of sabotage and intimidation. Instances in the Baltic states include arson, beatings and vandalism. Here in Britain, a similar attack targeted a Ukrainian-owned logistics company in London.

“Russia wants to sow fear, make us refrain from supplying Ukraine,” says Kallas. “We don’t understand how serious the situation is,” she complains. Allies should “join the dots” and stop treating these as isolated events, share information between governments and tell the public what is going on. The petty criminals who perpetrate the attacks should be punished more severely: under national security laws, not for criminal damage. Those caught in Estonia, she says, will be deported to Russia if they are not citizens. “The €3,000 they get [for an attack] does not outweigh going back to Russia for ever.”

She offers no easy answers, beyond consulting with (read: educating) allies who fail to see the threat. “If we don’t respond now, we’ll have more casualties.”

Kallas is unapologetically blunt, but with a deceptively friendly tone. Under pressure her Nordic cool hots up. She becomes more animated, eyes flashing. By Estonian standards, this is positively Italianate. It is also misleading. Kallas smiles a lot, but not always because she is pleased.

• See the latest on the Russia-Ukraine war

She also lives up to Estonians’ reputation for stubbornness. At her first EU summit after becoming prime minister in 2021, she single-handedly blocked an attempt by France and Germany to restore routine meetings with Russia. Other leaders from the continent’s east felt the same way. Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine should preclude any rapprochement. But none of them felt ready to speak up. The EU’s unspoken rules are that the big countries get their way on such things.

Nobody had told Kallas that. She simply refused to accept the pre-cooked consensus decision, making her case with the expertise of a corporate lawyer (her job before entering politics in 2011). Faced with her refusal to back down, Scholz and Macron, representing countries with a combined population nearly 120 times Estonia’s, buckled. EU ties with Russia have been frozen ever since.

Kallas keeps the shutters down about her life off-stage. A mildly interesting anecdote (easily found on the internet) about her first husband’s family that she mentions during our meeting causes her team to insist anxiously that the interview was already over when she said it. She has a son with a former partner. They announced their break-up, Estonian-style, in simultaneous social media posts. She got remarried to a businessman, and gets cross about any discussion of his minority shareholding in a logistics company that had a contract moving an Estonian company’s property out of Russia.

Kallas is an excellent dancer (waltz, not tango), and enjoys cooking Estonian forest mushrooms. She is visibly relieved when conversation turns to her main hobby, reading. Yale University historian Timothy Snyder, also visiting the conference, sets her eyes sparkling. She quotes extensively, from memory, from his works, from Plato, and from Not One Inch, the account of Nato enlargement. She read it on the beach in France, she explains. The thought that this might be a bit odd or seen as showing off does not cross her mind.

Although Kallas is lauded abroad, she is less popular at home. Her Reform party lost one of its two seats in the European parliament in the elections this month. The economy is flagging. Estonia’s vaunted progress in innovation seems to some observers to have stalled.

Kallas brushes worries aside, insisting the downturn is temporary and a new wave of technological innovation is coming. Reform represents go-getting professionals, the winners of the past 30 years. Older, poorer and rural Estonians feel left out. For all her ability to wow foreign audiences, Kallas has a tin ear for her own people, says a veteran commentator in Tallinn. A leading politician in a neighbouring country compliments her effectiveness: “Great internationally, but it’s all about her — not a team player.”

The other parties in her coalition government would agree. “Always making such good speeches abroad,” says a minister from another party. He then lapses into silence: a favourite Estonian conversational tactic. Kallas talks happily about how she starts her meetings bang on time. When her coalition partners turn up late, all the important decisions have been taken. That may be effective. It does not necessarily make her popular. Europeans will be lucky to have her in Brussels. Estonians will be delighted too.

Enter respectful comments here: