The west has to develop a war-winning strategy

View profile for Hans Petter Midttun, graphic

Hans Petter Midttun

Nonresident fellow hos Centre of Defence Strategies

June 23, 2024

European Pravda has published an interview you need to read. It asked Kurt Volker, a former US Ambassador to NATO and the US Special Representative for Ukraine negotiations (2017-19), about the war, NATO, Biden and Trump.

Some of the key points:

He believes that almost all of the Allies, except aside Germany, the US and Hungary, support an invitation for Ukraine to join NATO at the Washington Summit. He doesn’t see a way that permanent peace in Europe can be restored unless Ukraine is a part of NATO. We need clear lines. We must have an absence of grey zones where Putin is tempted to start a war.

If Biden wins a second term, he might decide “OK, now is the time”. Trump might say, “OK, if we’re going to end the war, part of ending the war is bringing Ukraine into NATO”. One can sell NATO membership as European burden-sharing.

Putin wants to rebuild the Russian empire and deny the right of people around Russia to have their own countries. They should be under Russia. It’s a very Hitlerian worldview. He is tactically very clever. He tries to sow divisions within Europe and NATO, undermine democracies, push narratives that are false and convince people that maybe he is reasonable and if you just don’t provoke him and maybe negotiate something, there is a solution.

Asked if he may be now preparing for a new escalation, Volker stresses that if Putin could escalate, he would already have done so. He has a lot of defence problems, including personnel, equipment, ammunition, leadership, command and control, morale, and more.

Tactical nuclear weapons remain an option. Putin’s military will, however, tell him it is not going to achieve anything, and it will bring retaliation against Russia. So better not to do it. And he can’t afford to give an order that his military doesn’t follow. He can’t really escalate. It is more about creating doubts and fears in the West.

The West have to develop a war-winning strategy. That is not happening right now. We are making incremental decisions about how to help Ukraine survive. It’s very incremental, and it is minimising rather than maximising.
The US fears escalation, other countries, nuclear weapons, Russia falling apart as a country, loose nukes inside Russia if that happens. A policy guided by fear is the opposite of a policy guided by purpose. The purpose should be to defeat Russia in Ukraine.

And whatever it takes to do that, including firing inside Russia and military targets, tightening sanctions against the Russian economy, providing Ukraine the weapons that it needs, lifting all restrictions, helping with freedom of navigation, strengthening the Black Sea security, maybe providing direct support for air defence so that Ukraine can move its air defences forward where they’re needed, helping Ukraine, especially with its energy sector, as we head into this winter so that there is no risk of power outages – those are all things we could and should be doing.

Cartoon: Financial Times

……….

“Trump doesn’t want Ukraine to become Afghanistan. It will be a catastrophe for him.” An interview with Kurt Volker

https://www.eurointegration.com.ua/eng/interview/2024/06/20/7188570/

3 comments

  1. For the life of me, I cannot think of a single Western leader who could conceive a clear-cut strategy that could end this war with a Ukrainian victory. We have no one that is qualified and with enough courage.

    • Maybe take politicians out of the equation and allow someone like Ben Wallace to come up with a plan, and be allowed implement it without interference.

      • That would work, if the ones in power would allow this.
        However, I’m quite sure that plenty of viable strategies have already been developed, but the leaders are just too spineless to implement them.

Enter respectful comments here: