This is not fiction

SIR RICHARD BRANSON

This is not fiction: https://virg.in/3AJ5HO

Virgin Galactic
Richard Branson's signature

Richard Branson

Published on 22 November 2024

“Give up your nuclear weapons (to us) and in return, we will guarantee to respect your sovereignty, your independence, and your borders.” So said Russia to Ukraine in 1994. “That is a great idea,” said the US and the UK. “The fewer countries that have nuclear weapons, the smaller is the chance of another world war. We, too, will guarantee your sovereignty, your independence, and make sure your borders are respected and protected.” 

This is not fiction. As more than 1000 days have now passed since Russia’s illegal and brutal invasion of Ukraine began, I am reminded once again of both the spirit and the words of the 1994 Budapest Memorandum, a treaty compelling Russia, the US, and the UK to offer security and sovereignty guarantees after Ukraine agreed to let go of the vast stockpile of nuclear weapons. The Memorandum’s key passages read as follows:

The United States of America, the Russian Federation, and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, reaffirm their commitment to Ukraine, in accordance with the principles of the CSCE [Commission on Security and Cooperation in Europe] Final Act, to respect the Independence and Sovereignty and the existing borders of Ukraine.

The United States of America, the Russian Federation, and the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, reaffirm their obligation to refrain from the threat or use of force against the territorial integrity or political independence of Ukraine, and that none of their weapons will ever be used against Ukraine except in self-defense or otherwise in accordance with the Charter of the United Nations

Russia’s commitment to the Memorandum was first shattered when it illegally invaded and annexed Crimea in 2014. Putin’s attack on 24 February 2022 removed any remaining doubt about his true intentions. Not faced with the deterrent of Ukraine’s nuclear weapons, Putin was out to absorb as much of Ukraine as he could while ignoring his pledge to the people of Ukraine and to the world.

Richard Branson with a family in Ukraine
Helen Clarke

But Russia’s complete disregard for the Budapest Memorandum doesn’t just cast a dark shadow on Ukraine’s future. It’s also a slap in the face of multilateral institutions and their difficult work to negotiate complex agreements, particularly when it comes to disarmament. After seeing what happened to Ukraine, which country in possession of nuclear weapons, at present or in the future, will ever agree to give up its arsenal again? And sadly, which country that doesn’t have nuclear weapons now will be next to seek them as a deterrent? 

Most people have never heard of the Budapest Memorandum and the important commitments enshrined in it. But if treaties like it cannot be relied on when relationships between nations sour, what other options does the world have left before it descends into anarchy or worse? For those of us who grew up believing in the power of global cooperation to solve conflict and tackle the tough challenges we all face, this doesn’t bode well. The rule of law is under attack, and it’s time to defend it in words and in actions.

…………………….

Comment from :

Steven Moore

This is important to know. In 1994, Ukraine had more nuclear weapons than any country but the US and Russia. They gave them up in exchange for guarantees that they would be defended by the UK, US and Russia should any of those countries violate Ukraine’s sovereignty.

Seemed like a good idea at the time.

………

Comment from Mark Millot

Great points Richard Branson and Steven Moore , but remember the actual agreements (Budapest Memorandum) did not give Ukraine “security guarantees” but “security assurances” These are vastly different obligations. The US and UK were unwilling to take the bold step to actually help maintain and enforce Ukranian sovereignty. Bill Clinton has said repeatedly that he feels terrible about the weakness of the agreement based on the situation Ukraine is in today. Let’s hope this entire process doesn’t repeat itself again in the near future. The Ukranian people deserve better from both the UK and the US.

Russell Davidson

One can draw legalistic distinctions such as that, Mark, but the fact remains that the West gave assurances sufficient to convince the Ukrainians to relinquish their one weapon that might have deterred Putin. There have followed twenty years of Russian interference in Ukrainian politics and then Crimea (part of Ukraine) was annexed in 2014.

The West did nothing until the invasion of 2022, and even then the response of its major powers has been slow and timeous.

Why would any country ever agree in future not to acquire nuclear weapons or to give them up? The prosperous countries of Western Europe in particular have been shaken out of their fantasy about their neighbour dictators being persuaded to become democrats through trade, and now they must address the misguided idea that they can always rely on the USA to foot the bill for their defence. That process still has a long way to go. Poland and the Baltic States fully understand. Too many other European countries are still on the learning curve.

Akos Magyar

Russell Davidson Ukraine had little choice. The West bullied it into signing using economics and political isolation. It wasn’t just the nukes, Ukraine’s Soviet forces were dismantled and sold all over the place, many items by Victor Boot. Helicopters ended up in Africa and the Middle East, the bombers in Russia and other former republics of the USSR, guns and ammo went all over the world. It was a fire sale that rendered Ukraine a broken state with an almost nominal military.

Russel Davidson

Which makes the West’s dereliction of duty even worse.

Nedder McDonnell

Russell Davidson The Ukrainians had little choice but to accede. Remember this was 1994 and Ukraine would have been unable to stave off a Red Army invasion. What stinks is that the U.S. and U.K. claim they are in compliance with the Memorandum. By the wording, they are. The U.K., in fairness to her, has tried to prod the U.S. periodically, at least under Prime Minister Johnson (of all people).
https://nedmcdletters.blogspot.com/2014/03/letters-to-friends-and-family-94.html (from March 2014)
The split here is not over the wording but over whether the U.S. and the U.K. implicitly assumed a moral mandate NOT IN THE WORDING of that wretched Memorandum. I believe they did and I see the appeasement of ten years ago as shameful and the current hesitance as lethal to Ukraine.

https://nedmcdletters.blogspot.com/2014/03/letters-to-friends-and-family-94.html?m=1

One comment

  1. “Let’s hope this entire process doesn’t repeat itself again in the near future.”

    No, it won’t repeat itself again.
    It won’t repeat, simply because no other nation will ever give up its nukes for a worthless piece of paper after seeing what happened to Ukraine.
    In effect, the final outcome of the Budapest Memorandum is the same as a death sentence for any further nuclear disarmament. In fact, the BM brought the opposite outcome, because it encourages more nations to acquire nukes. You cannot really rely on wobbly allies, but you can rely on your nukes.

Enter respectful comments here: