Russia May Have Just Given Ukraine Terms for Ending War

9/26/23

Vladimir putin (left) delivers a speech during the State Council’s Presidium on September 21, 2023, in Veliky Novgorod, russia. Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky during a press conference on September 6, 2023, in Kyiv, Ukraine. A Kremlin official suggested Russia may be open to ending the war in Ukraine if Kyiv agrees to not join a military alliance.PHOTOS BY YAN DOBRONOSOV/GLOBAL IMAGES UKRAINE/GETTY IMAGES

A top kremlin official on Saturday suggested russia could agree to an end to the war in Ukraine if a key condition is met.

During a press conference at the United Nations General Assembly, russian Foreign Minister sergey lavrov indicated Russia would recognize Ukraine’s borders prior to moscow’s invasion if Kyiv pledges to not join a military alliance.

Since russian president vladimir putin began the war on February 24, 2022, he and kremlin officials have cited various justifications for the conflict. But one of the most frequently stated reasons is putin’s opposition to the expansion of NATO on his country’s borders, and he is said to be especially against Ukraine becoming a member of the military bloc.

Lavrov told reporters that in 1991, moscow “recognized the sovereignty of Ukraine on the basis of the Declaration of Independence, which it adopted upon leaving the USSR.”

“One of the main points for us was that Ukraine would be a non-aligned country and would not enter into any military alliances,” Lavrov said. “Under those conditions, we support the territorial integrity of this state.”

George Mason University Schar School of Policy and Government professor Mark N. Katz told Newsweek that “Ukraine’s 1990 Declaration of State Sovereignty does indeed proclaim Ukraine to be a ‘permanently neutral state that does not participate in military blocs.’

“Lavrov’s statement, then, does imply that moscow would recognize Ukraine’s 1990 borders if Ukraine foreswore membership in NATO.”

Newsweek reached out to the russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs via email for comment.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has been pushing since the start of the war for his country to be made part of NATO, and his efforts have gained the support of key NATO officials. But even if Zelensky agreed to relinquish the bid for NATO membership in order to end the war, Ukraine would likely still find a sticking point on the issue of Crimea.

Putin invaded and annexed Crimea in 2014, and Zelensky has vowed to reclaim the peninsula as part of his nation. Following the breakup of the Soviet Union, Crimea was declared Ukraine’s, which has led some to speculate that Lavrov may have hinted that Russia could be willing to give up the region.

Katz said that while Crimea was a province of Ukrainian Soviet Socialist Republic in 1990, he has a feeling that “Lavrov’s statement might not be definitive, and that there may be further ‘clarification’ about it that is not so generous toward Ukraine.

“Still, if moscow just wants to end the war, it may be able to portray forestalling Ukraine from joining NATO as a victory even if it means renouncing russian claims to occupied Ukrainian territory.

“But I’m not sure putin can do this as it would raise the question of whether the enormous casualties experienced by russian forces in this conflict were worth such an agreement—assuming that Ukraine and NATO governments would agree to it.”

David Silbey, an associate professor of history at Cornell and director of teaching and learning at Cornell in Washington, told Newsweek that he found Lavrov’s statement and how it relates to Crimea “ambiguous, which is interesting in and of itself.

“It would have been easy for Lavrov to make the distinction clear, but he didn’t, and he wouldn’t do something like this without having clearance from putin. They both have to know that this would immediately raise questions about Crimea.”

Even if russia isn’t willing to return Crimea to Ukraine, Lavrov’s comments could be interpreted to mean putin might relinquish his claim to the Donetsk, Kherson, Luhansk and Zaporizhzhia oblasts. A year ago, putin announced that the four Ukrainian regions were annexed to Russia in a move that the international community called illegitimate.

“In terms of the four territories, I think, yes, it does suggest that the russians are willing to give them back,” Silbey said.

https://www.newsweek.com/russia-may-have-just-given-ukraine-terms-ending-war-1829980

24 comments

  1. This is a clear sign of weakness. I doubt that the mafiosi would be willing to surrender Crimea, but this doesn’t change the fact that mafia land realizes its only losing this war.
    As for NATO’s role for Ukraine, in the course of the various happenings in the past ten or so years, I’ve steadily lost confidence in NATO. This war has heightened my dislike of this organization. Recent events have even turned it into disdain. I simply can’t see this alliance to be anything else except ineffective, save the most extreme case of nuclear attack.
    Thus, I think it’s a good idea that maybe Ukraine could take this offer into consideration. Of course, if the mafiosi won’t relent Crimea, then this makes their offer null and void.

    • It’s very generous of russia to offer back the parts of Ukraine that are totally destroyed, and no doubt would be looted of everything not nailed down, if Ukraine agreed to this deal. I say press on with this counteroffensive, then see what kind of deal the scum want when Ukraine are knocking on the door of Crimea.

    • Peace plan: GET THE FUCK OUT OF UKRAINE. PERIOD.

      Professor Katz apparently not considering the unprovoked attacks, rapes, murder, etc. in moving beyond any notions of neutrality. Sorry, you started it Ruzzia, now fuck off and Ukraine can do whatever it wants as a sovereign country. Won’t need NATO, if we give them the nukes they gave up. Just sayin.

  2. Don’t fall for this BS. As we all know, mafialand and promises are never kept. Ukraine vow never to join NATO, everything goes well for a few years, russia builds it’s destroyed army back up, then invades again, using some far fetched excuse. Next time the support from the West would almost certainly be impossible. Ukraine have got to smash the orcs this time, and sign no fucking agreements.

    • I completely agree with you. Orcland only seeks to maintain a position of permanent aggressor towards Ukraine. They will do everything to prevent Ukraine from being subservient to a defense group.

      “…back up, then invades again, using some far fetched excuse.”

      I think the next attack in this possible situation would be much more massive, extremely rapid and destructive. It would certainly be nuclear at a time when no one expects it.

  3. Any deal has to include Crimea.

    Any deal involving non-membership of NATO is fine.

    Agreements made under coercion are not enforceable.

  4. No negotiations, no deals. The pain of Ukraine has been too great for that.
    RuZZia in its present form must die, the kremlin murder gang put in The Hague and full reparations paid before any talking.

  5. I realize that mafia deals are worthless.
    However, mafia land isn’t the only country that can rearm. So can Ukraine. Ukraine will do so regardless of what happens. It will also do things differently to make another invasion impossible. It will remove all those damned mines and plant them thickly all along the border with the shithole, plus many more. It is already in a partnership to build tanks and other fighting vehicles with foreign partners. And, I don’t think that Ukraine will be left completely alone when the next war comes, if it comes. We can’t forget that the runt isn’t the youngest anymore and although this doesn’t guarantee a future of peace when he finally goes to hell, the chances are diminished. Furthermore, the confiscate assets should go to Ukraine in any deal and further reparations should be paid by mafia land. War criminals must be handed over, maybe even the runt himself.
    Ukraine should do what it can to make the best of this. It’s obvious that it can because mafia land is a sinking ship.

    • Is that an original Newsweek article that you subedited Frankie Facts?!
      Inserting such words as “dicktator” etc?!
      The author might not mind, but you never know!

  6. probably all this says that the fascist ruling class has understood that – by the mechanism it has put in place, by the choices it has made – that its survival is increasingly threatened.

    their choice is to abandon Ukraine or explode… they have lost their ability to support Armenia, their defense industry will only give ground, the Ukrainians have shown them that they have the means to act on all the means of domination that the Russian fascists have.

    moreover, if the Russian and Ukrainian peoples are really intertwined, that means that it is unmanageable for Russia: even if it closes like North Korea, even behind an iron curtain, it will have a 5th column which will only grow up… if it has to chase away internal enemies in an ever-increasing paranoia, manage the broken faces of war, the birth rate and their demographic problem are not ready to stop… for the moment poutine distributes his war chest which was to last 3 years. afterwards surrounded by greedy thieves he will no longer have an asset.

    it is a clash between two modes of governance and influence which in my opinion will come to an end, we must be able to analyze the intensity and the speed, to limit the explosion but that’s all… the confrontation is everywhere in the financing of European far-right movements in conspiracy and separatist movements in all their forms (the Trump sect)…

    Ukraine is a little Russia. it is a competitor in all areas: agriculture, minerals, energy… they are reliable unlike Russia. They wanted to overturn international law, and now we would have to believe that Putin touched by grace would want to develop his country and make it attractive? and ask for forgiveness for the suffering? have the fascists of the dictatorship changed? a dictatorship has its own characteristics and problems, predictable behavior. apart from changing the system software nothing will change. the same causes produce the effects…

    a land of plenty cannot be adjacent to a brutal swamp, especially if some of the inhabitants of the swamp have family in the land of plenty, this is not a situation for the future, a lasting situation. Putin and his philosophy and his management cannot keep power… we can cushion his fall but that’s it – in my opinion.

    if poutine had changed his behavior quickly before Butcha, but now he’s too far, he’s shown us too much how hard he tried to fuck us. Putin is no longer the rght man at the right place.

    • (I’m trying to correct this passage a little in the translation)
      it is a clash between two modes of governance and influence which in my opinion will lead to the supremacy of one of the two in Europe, we must be able to channel/control the intensity and speed of the conflict, to limit the explosion but it that’s all… the confrontation was carried everywhere by Putin, in the financing of European far-right movements, in conspiracy and separatist movements in all their forms (the Trump sect), in the influence on the elections in democratic countries… increase Europe’s immigration problems…
      when the West invested in Russia, Putin in gratitude brought chaos to our countries…

  7. Peace comes only if

    1. Russia demilitarizes
    2. Russia denazifies
    3. Russia gives up its empire and keeps itself inside its original borders west of the Urals
    4. Reparations are paid
    5. Putin, and others are given up to the ICC to be tried for war crimes
    6. Russia leaves all of Ukraine, and Georgia

    Feel free to add more.

  8. What this is a tact admission that Ukraine strike anywhere in Crimea with devastating effect and there is little Russia can to do to stop it. Crimea for all intents purposes is untenable. So they want to get out with something to show for all the bloodshed and mayhem they have caused preferably with the political asses intact.
    Like the parable of the scorpion and the frog, I don’t trust them. it is their nature to take and kill regardless of the cost to themselves and those around them.
    They NEVER bargain in good faith.
    That being said the chance the regain all of Ukraine’s territory with out loosing more of their people and destroying more land should be considered.
    As a practical matter with Odban and possibly other leaders Ukraine is not getting into NATO anytime soon. I don’t like it but there is is.
    But putin will not last forever and as Russia has ably demonstrated what can be agreed to today can be ignored tomorrow.
    And it says Ukraine can’t join a MILITARY block. that does not mean they can’t join the EU or develop bilateral relationships. Ukraine is already developed the ground work with Sweden. Poland, Cechia, UK, the US. and to an excent Germany. plus they can remain a Partnership for Peace member.(that is no joining.)

    • I also think that Ukraine’s chances to join NATO are not very good. There are certain entities who are against it. They, too, should be thrown out. But, NATO is a very unflexible organization. A major flaw in its essence.

      • I think I’ve understood that for the moment neither the USA nor Germany are in favour of Ukraine joining NATO. One of the reasons, and it’s a good one, is corruption. If you’re going to share secrets and procedures, there has to be a minimum of trust. and it’s the same for the EU.
        On the other hand, we can see that it hasn’t bothered Putin much that NATO has expanded recently… perhaps because their people are less intertwined with the Russian people than the Ukrainian people. Either Putin is threatened by the attractiveness of democracy and can’t say so publicly, so he talks about the threat of NATO…

        either like the first stone of the Russian Empire, Great Russia, is made up of Belarus and Ukraine, letting them go into another whole will make the Putinist imperialist dream very very distant and its path with even more obstacles …
        but if Putin had invested in his country to make it attractive, and if he had ceded power democratically, so that others could in turn seed this country, by improving the links between the countries of the federation, by deepening the links of marriage through a mutual enrichment, Russia would have solved its problem of alcoholism, demographics, national pride, instead Putin behaved like a rapist, disgusted or even murdered all men of good will and put /still endangers all of humanity, the ignorant and ostriches too – not just Westerners.
        Darwin calls Putin and his collaborators.

        • This has much more to do with than just corruption. The West is much more corrupt than it would like to admit. Just take a glance at all those Western components that are inside ruskie missiles and iranian drones.
          Our sanctions as a whole are ludicrous. We’ve allowed so many loopholes and exceptions that they are not nearly as effective as we lied about when the war started, just to protect the interests of banks and conglomerates.
          Secrets? It was the US that leaked secrets about this war early this year, and not Ukraine. Ukraine had been very good at keeping secrets. So, this can’t be an argument, either.

        • I don’t entirely agree with the corruption argument.

          If it is a determining element for accessing NATO, then what are Turkey, Albania, North Macedonia (see corruption index) doing within it? Incidentally, note that Turkey maintains close relations with the Kremlin on a daily basis! Isn’t this a most corrupt posture?!

          Yes there are problems of corruption in Ukrainian society. no one denies it. But leaving the fold of the Kremlin and its influence is in some ways also a fight to get rid of corruption.

          Moreover, is there no better reason to integrate (in Nato) Ukraine than its fight against an enemy which alone represents the existential justification of NATO! It’s obvious.

          Corruption is unfortunately global. In recent years, the Kremlin has distributed hundreds of millions of dollars in bribes to different parties and Western organizations to gain their support. We are talking about it?

          • The bribes and bought favors by mafia land in the West are closely guarded secrets. The mafia’s tentacles have spread far and wide, maybe even into places we would never have thought of.

  9. @OFP
    (I specify the difficulties of translation, reduce the expression of my thoughts…)

    for corruption, it exists everywhere, it is inherent in human life. time corrupts systems and people. We can probably already say that the older a man gets, the more likely he is to be corrupt.
    in the West it is seen as a cancer, and it is fought in a general, structural way, particularly because it is a misappropriation/theft of the common good. it would seem that in the former communist countries, probably in reaction to a certain hypocrisy of these political systems which claimed to be more virtuous and more egalitarian, a corruption developed that some call “cultural” (funny example of corruption of a mind: “they pretended to pay us, we pretended to work.” where did the notion of the common good go?)
    In a whole part of the world the populations are old and this has consequences: for example Putin can rely on a large population of old Soviet nostalgics. without this aging (a consequence of WWII) this drift would probably not have been possible.
    Putin’s Russia led a hybrid war and corrupted everyone it wanted to influence: Ukraine, Europe, US, etc… it’s obvious.
    my point is never to denigrate, of course. I always speak with kindness except towards fascists.

    we know that sanctions encourage smuggling and have perverse effects – but if there are no mass SU57s or T14s it is thanks to the 2014 sanctions. it is not because it is imperfect that it’s rubbish. even a strainer obstructs a flow. an expert explained that the chips needed for fascist missiles fit in a backpack!
    This gives the measure of the challenge to be taken up…
    even seizing money from mafia oligarchs could have repercussions and will probably have perverse effects whose consequences are difficult to measure today. In short, nothing is simple and every medal has its other side. life unfortunately is often about choosing a lesser evil… but that doesn’t mean we have to give up doing better…

    You point out some of our contradictions (we are not a homogeneous body, we can regret it even if it seems inevitable to me – by the way, builders build under the gaze/malice of pests and/or destroyers.) but it nonetheless remains true that indeed our worst threat is the inconsistency of our systems, of our behaviours.
    nothing is taken for granted in life, the search for the good, of the balance, of justice is a permanent struggle, everything is a confrontation between order and chaos (or more precisely between some established orders, under construction and some chaos, companies/movements of destruction).

    for NATO, I had heard that the USA did not want to deprive itself of a negotiation option/possibility.
    personally – without deeply measuring the consequences and without having privileged information which allows me to reflect in depth – I am for Ukraine to join NATO and the EU.
    firstly because it is a reversible process… and if the world changes we will be able to imagine/create something else – in my opinion: Ukrainians deserve to be safe, whatever the final arrangement, it will be necessary just for it to be effective. Ukrainians deserve to have real allies, to develop and live in peace.
    for me, a goal to achieve is to cast out Russian imperialism, and move forward on the virtuous emancipation of the Russian people, their development – to bring security, stability, prosperity to Europe.

Enter respectful comments here: