OPINION: Donald Trump Is To Be the President: Let’s Not Dramatize

Ukraine grows weaker each day under the relentless strain of this war. That’s why we need consistency, commitment, and a clear-eyed understanding of the reality here at home.

By Iuliia Mendel

With the announcement of the US presidential election results, social media predictably erupted in drama, particularly concerning Ukraine’s future. Many experts and journalists have been convinced that Donald Trump’s presidency would spell disaster for Ukraine. However, the reality is far more sober than social media drama: neither candidate offered a clear win for Ukraine.

Having closely followed both campaigns, I noted that Trump’s clearest stance on Ukraine was his call to “end the war.” Many interpreted this as a veiled call for capitulation, but the truth is more nuanced. That message resonates deeply with a less vocal group of Ukrainians – those enduring daily bombardments, whose lives have been reduced to an unending cycle of destruction since Russia’s full-scale invasion.

A year ago, the New York Times wrote that Ukraine would inevitably face a difficult choice: preserve its people or its territories. Three years into this war, with closed borders, a collapsing economy, and an exodus of citizens, this observation has only grown more poignant. Our national discourse remains fixated on territorial gains as the ultimate measure of victory, while the true battle is for the survival of the Ukrainian nation itself.

Ukraine grows weaker each day under the relentless strain of this war. That’s why we need consistency, commitment, and a clear-eyed understanding of the reality here at home.

Calls to pause the war, even temporarily, to preserve the nation are often dismissed as naive, typically by those far from the frontlines. Critics argue, “Putin will attack again.” This rationale, however, seems to demand that we justify staggering human losses and the potential extinction of Ukraine on the basis of a hypothetical future threat. In essence: die now to avoid possibly dying later.

A purely military solution has never been a viable path to victory for Ukraine, even with unlimited Western financial and military support. This is not a critique of our armed forces – our soldiers, both professional and civilian, have shown extraordinary bravery and resilience in defending democracy against Russian tyranny. However, we must confront the sobering reality: the cost of this war is steadily eroding the very foundation of the Ukrainian nation.

Who is more naive? Me, who speaks with people across Ukraine and receives their messages of urgency, or those who draw conclusions from TikTok and Twitter, clinging to official statements? Naivety can be dangerous. It can cost lives – thousands of them in our case.

Do I believe Donald Trump will or can end the war? I have no idea. What I do know is that in the highest offices of Western politicians and diplomats, discussions of a ceasefire have been ongoing for a long time. A ceasefire, however imperfect, may be the best we can hope for in the near term.

During a ceasefire, we could build the fortifications we failed to construct before the invasion and cannot erect now under constant shelling. We could partially restore our fragile, collapsing economy. We could reopen our borders, hold elections, and demonstrate to the world that we have preserved the democracy for which we’ve been fighting. There is so much more we must rebuild to safeguard our human capital – healthcare, education, and infrastructure. A ceasefire would also give us the breathing room to strengthen our military, continuing its training and preparation. If Putin were to attack again, we would be far better prepared, standing on firmer ground than we are now in this exhausting war of attrition.

On the matter of our territories: since the failed counteroffensive of 2023, Ukraine has not had a realistic chance to reclaim the land. No amount of support on Twitter will change that. In fact, we have lost more territory in recent months – around 478 square kilometers (184 square miles) between August and September alone – than during the entirety of 2023.

This isn’t solely the West’s fault. If they didn’t care, they wouldn’t have provided the immense support we received in 2022 and 2023. But the hard truth remains: regaining our territories will require time, strategic patience, and a combination of military strength and diplomatic savvy.

For now, Ukraine grows weaker each day under the relentless strain of this war. That’s why we need consistency, commitment, and a clear-eyed understanding of the reality here at home. Dramatic rhetoric will not help us persevere. We must approach the choices of the American people – and the global community – with cool minds and open hearts.

Iuliia Mendel is a Ukrainian journalist and political advisor. She was the press secretary in the administration of Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy from June 3, 2019 until July 9, 2021.

https://www.kyivpost.com/opinion/41788

12 comments

  1. “Putin will attack again.” This rationale, however, seems to demand that we justify staggering human losses and the potential extinction of Ukraine on the basis of a hypothetical future threat.”

    This woman was the press secretary to Zelensky. She sounds more like the press secretary to the Kremlin. She is very naive if she thinks the countless threats coming out of mafia land to destroy Ukraine are hypothetical.

    • Ukraine needs peace. Too many fathers and husbands are crippled, too many lives were lost and a giant financial burden is about to break Ukraine’s back. Even if Trump would push Nato to act, Germany, Hungary and Turkey would sabotage such efforts.

      • If Ukraine are forced to accept putlers terms, then the bloodshed will have just started. There will be no Ukraine in a few years time.

        • I’m a bit more optimistic, also i doubt Ukraine will accept a peace entirely on Putin’s terms, a compromise is more likely since both sides wasted too many human resources.

          • I don’t share that optimism. The kremlin don’t care about lives of their military, they never have. The only thing that will make putin stop, is the threat of flooding Ukraine with enough weapons to deter russia. I don’t see that happening.

            • A pruSSian clown started WWI and paved the way for Hitler. I don’t think further escalation will serve Ukrainian interests, since Ukraine is (unfortunately) not on par with ruSSia. But i respect your devotion.

              • It’s not devotion. I’m just looking at the alternatives. russia has never adhered to any ceasefire, so I don’t see that changing anytime soon. Putin can wait until Trump is out of the way, rearm and attack Ukraine again.

                • Territorial concessions will of course only be acceptable in exchange for security guarantees by the US and Nato. To make sure the scenario you pointed out will never happen, and i don’t mean Buddha-Pest.

                • And that’s what I think will happen. IF Trump is wise, and IF he gets better advisors this time, he may present a cease fire and when Poopin violates the ceasefire, Trump loads up Ukraine. It has nothing to do with territory, just a ceasefire.

  2. There we are : the “land for peace” movement inside Ukraine is emerging.
    Unfortunately the rat nazi will not offer a ceasefire without massive concessions from Ukraine. Why should he? He’s got the CRINK’s, the BRICS and now the putler wing of the GOP serving his interests.

    • There we are:
      “Trump’s clearest stance on Ukraine was his call to “end the war.” Many interpreted this as a veiled call for capitulation, but the truth is more nuanced.”

Enter respectful comments here: