Not ‘A New Yalta.’ The Trump-Putin-Xi Summit Is Something Worse.

A novel kind of geopolitical farce

Nov 20, 2026

Donald Trump, Vladimir Putin, and Xi Jinping held a summit in Shenzhen, China today, and commentators are already calling it “a new Yalta.”

They’re wrong. What happened in Shenzhen isn’t a new Yalta, but a novel kind of geopolitical farce.

The “new Yalta” moniker is a reference to a conference held in the eponymous Crimean resort town in the closing days of World War II. With Germany and Japan near defeat, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Winston Churchill, and Joseph Stalin sketched out the contours of the post-war world.

Yalta has become infamous in parts of Eastern Europe, a byword for appeasement much like Munich. The Western Allies consigned Poland—and half the continent—to more than four decades of communist domination. The implication of a new Yalta is that Trump, Putin, and Xi are dividing up the world again, leaving smaller countries like Ukraine behind.

Yet context makes it clear how much more shameful Trump’s actions at Shenzhen are than what happened at Yalta.

We can condemn the betrayal of Poland in 1945, but it’s important to recall that Stalin already controlled Eastern Europe, with the Red Army standing over 10 million strong. Reversing this would have meant war between the Western Allies and the USSR.

By contrast, Russia has barely been able to advance in Ukraine in nearly five years. Donald Trump is not making difficult compromises; he is voluntarily capitulating to a third-rate power. Trump called Russia’s genocidal dictator, the butcher of Mariupol, “friend,” because the president of the United States craves attention and adoration.

It’s also worth noting that FDR and Churchill did secure a few victories at Yalta, such as Stalin’s much-belated entry into the war against Japan. Roosevelt also got Soviet buy-in for the nascent United Nations, to be headquartered in the US and dominated by the West. Trump left Shenzhen with national shame for America and a vague memo about “peace.”

Trump’s critics are not the only ones embracing the Yalta framing. Consider Vladimir Putin. Oh, how Putin would love to be Joseph Stalin. But Stalin ruled the USSR at the height of its power. When the Soviet dictator met with Roosevelt and Churchill, his armies were mere miles from Berlin. Last month, the Russian military endured record losses in Ukraine, and Putin needs the American president’s cooperation in order to win there.

Trump is no Franklin Delano Roosevelt, though he’d certainly like a third or fourth term. The current president is a lame-duck 80-year-old who brought his party to a historic defeat in this month’s midterms. Roosevelt came to Yalta with Western Europe and the Pacific newly under Washington’s suzerainty. When Trump arrived in Shenzhen, he left American leverage at the door. He even abandoned the US press corps to China’s censors.

That leaves the host, Xi Jinping. Of the three men in Shenzhen, Xi is the only one presiding over a rising power. China’s GDP growth continues to outpace America’s. China’s stock of nuclear weapons is also the world’s fastest-expanding. Trump suggested that he wanted to curb China’s growing arsenal, but he walked out of Shenzhen with no concrete achievements on that front.

There’s one more critical difference with Yalta. In 1945, the US, the British Empire, and the Soviet Union were the only consequential world powers. Germany and Japan lay in ruins. France had only just been liberated. Many countries were still colonies.

At Shenzhen, Putin said that Russia, China, and America are “united […] by the status of victors in the Second World War,” as if history ground to a halt eight decades ago. Today, there are other players in global politics. Ukraine is the leading innovator in modern warfare. Europe is an economic powerhouse and a serious (albeit dormant) military force. Japan has been rebuilt. Nations like India, South Korea, Canada, and Brazil pull their weight as well. They will look at Trump’s surrender, at the way Putin puts on a charade of Soviet-era strength, and at Xi’s calculations, and make their own decisions.

Modern pundits use “Yalta” as an analytical shorthand for a scenario in which world leaders carve up the map and make concessions to dictators. It seems we will have to broaden our imaginations, because today’s Trump-Putin-Xi summit belongs to an entirely different category of treachery. It was a burlesque performance in which aging leaders acted out their idealized pasts, in which the president of the United States threw up his hands before a murderous tyrant and dubbed him a “friend.” In the future, perhaps we’ll have another one-word descriptor for this sort of thing: Shenzhen.

Garry Kasparov is the chairman of the Renew Democracy Initiative, which publishes The Next Move.

https://rdi.org/

3 comments

  1. Shaun Pinner :

    Russia’s barbaric acts continue to mount, yet Donald Trump’s reported comments today, suggesting he would discuss ways to protect Putin and Xi from the International Criminal Court (ICC), are frankly disgusting.

    At this very moment, Putin is attempting to manufacture a humanitarian disaster in Ukraine, weaponising winter, destroying critical infrastructure and leaving civilians without electricity, heating and water.

    The United Nations has already documented Russian atrocities, including war crimes and crimes against humanity, while the ICC has issued arrest warrants for Putin over the unlawful deportation and transfer of Ukrainian children.

    Children!!!

    And now we have the President of the United States reportedly discussing how to shield these leaders from international accountability, from the country that proudly calls itself “the land of the free and the home of the brave.”

  2. Chameleon magazine published a treacherous pro-Putler article headed :

    BURNHAM’S KILLING PLAN: NOT VOTED ON BY THE BRITISH PEOPLE — BUT FUNDED IN THEIR NAME!

    I responded :

    What a disgraceful, morally bankrupt article.
    Such kremkrapp could easily have been written by Sergei Lavrov.
    Reminder : Ukraine, a close ally of the U.K., is currently defending itself from genocide and indescribable savagery being inflicted by a regime that in evil and ideology is no different from the Third Reich.
    The U.K. is a signatory of the Budapest Memorandum. Look it up.

    The editor replied :

    “Britain did not sign up to kill Russians simply because Ukraine is an ally.
    The Budapest Memorandum was an agreement to respect Ukraine’s sovereignty and provide security assurances. It was not a declaration of war, a military alliance or a blank cheque for Britain to attack Russia.
    Nobody is denying Ukraine’s right to defend itself against invasion. But supporting Ukraine does not mean the British people have automatically consented to Britain becoming a direct participant in this war.
    And questioning military escalation does not make someone a supporter of Putin or a mouthpiece for Sergei Lavrov.
    Britain can support Ukraine without giving any government an unquestionable mandate to kill Russians in the name of the British people.
    If you believe Britain should become directly involved in attacking Russia, make that argument openly. But don’t pretend the British public signed up for it in 1994.”

    I replied to the prick :

    The U.K. is in fact doing a lot less than the bare minimum for Ukraine, which is suffering genocide from savages.
    If you read John Major’s contemporary notes, he believed that he was, with the U.S., providing a “nuclear umbrella” for Ukraine.
    Why would the Ukrainians sign something that condemned them to certain future attack from Russia unless they believed that security assurances meant exactly that?
    President Kravchuk of Ukraine expressed extreme misgivings at the last minute about the Memorandum to Bill Clinton, as Yeltsin had invaded Moldova and Georgia and was inflicting genocide in Chechnya.
    Clinton flew to Kyiv to reassure him that Ukraine would be fully protected.
    It’s pretty clear that you take your line on Russia from Nigel Farage, who with his friend George Galloway, worked for RT for the best part of two decades.
    It is also clear that you share Trump’s murderous hatred of Ukraine.
    Only you know why.

    He replied again :

    “I couldn’t give a damn what John Major, Bill Clinton or any other politician thought they were promising thirty years ago.
    None of them was given a blank cheque to kill innocent Russian civilians in the name of the British people.
    Ukraine has every right to defend itself against invasion. But that does not give British politicians an automatic mandate to escalate military involvement without democratic accountability.
    If our politicians believe Britain should go to war with Russia in support of Ukraine, then have the courage to say so openly, make the case to Parliament and the British people, and accept responsibility for the consequences.
    Instead, they appear happy to support the development of long-range weapons capable of striking deep inside Russia while insisting Britain is not at war.
    That is like throwing bricks from the back of the crowd while expecting somebody else to take the punches.
    And spare me the nonsense about Farage, Galloway and Trump. I don’t need any of them to tell me what to think.
    My position is simple: I oppose the deliberate killing of innocent civilians, whether they are Ukrainian or Russian.
    If you want Britain involved in a war, argue for it openly. Don’t hide behind John Major and a thirty-year-old memorandum.”

    I replied again :

    You are a pro-Russia commenter hiding behind equivocation.
    Putin is a child murderer, a serial killer and invader who is unfortunately backed by Trump, who regardless of whether he is or isn’t, behaves exactly as a Russian agent would behave.
    All the U.K. is doing is trying to help Ukraine defend itself. Like Trump you are upset about Russian deaths but completely indifferent to genocide in Ukraine.

    • He came back again with :

      “And you’re a war-hungry arsehole who resorts to name-calling because you can’t come up with a better argument, dickhead.
      Condemning Putin’s invasion and opposing the killing of innocent Russians are not mutually exclusive.
      I have never defended Putin or the invasion of Ukraine. That’s something you’ve invented because it’s easier than addressing what I’m actually saying.
      I oppose the killing of innocent civilians, Ukrainian or Russian. You seem to have a problem understanding that.
      My argument is about British taxpayers’ money, military escalation and politicians taking responsibility for their decisions.
      If you want Britain to become directly involved in a war with Russia, have the courage to argue for it openly.
      And if your only response to someone questioning government policy is to call them a Russian sympathiser, perhaps it’s you who’s run out of arguments.”

      My final reply :

      Like all morally bankrupt putler-rimmers, you resort to ad hom attacks when your lies fall apart.

Enter respectful comments here: