Nato involvement in Ukraine must not be off the table in 2023

We cannot delude ourselves – this war is likely to get worse this year. We have to be prepared for anything and plan accordingly

Hamish de Bretton-Gordon

4 January 2023 •

A soldier from Carpathian Sich international battalion fires an RPG while conducting manoeuvres near the front line
A soldier from the Carpathian Sich international battalion fires an RPG while conducting manoeuvres near the front line CREDIT: CLODAGH KILCOYNE/REUTERS

There has only been one Cold War so far in history, one – thank goodness – that never went Hot.

To some, that means that the fate of our new “Cold War II” will head in a similar direction: sabre-rattling, eruptions of violence, but never into an all out war between major powers.

I hope and pray that remains the case, but it is not a certainty – which is why I am alarmed by those who seem to think there is next to zero chance that Nato will intervene in Ukraine in 2023.

What if, to posit one example, Putin were to launch some sort of dirty bomb or nuclear incident at Zaporizhia? What if Putin’s second offensive on Kyiv was successful, its government and population threatened? What if the Ukrainians successfully attacked Crimea and Putin ramps up the nuclear dial yet further? Could the West really stand by in all circumstances?

We need to be frank with ourselves: if we are truly committed to our values and moral standpoints, and so is Russia to its imperialist, fascistic worldview, escalation this year is arguably more rather than less likely.

Putin made it pretty clear in his New Year remarks that he already sees Russia as at war with the West. The devastating attack on Makiivka barracks by Ukrainian HIMARS, perhaps killing hundreds of Russian soldiers, is likely to reinforce this view amongst his henchmen.

This danger is why it is doubly important to do two things: to seek to end this war as soon as possible by providing the Ukrainians with the weapons they need, and second – as I continue to argue – to make it clear to Russia exactly where our red lines are. Anything less could escalate this war beyond Ukraine and beyond even conventional conflict.

To expand on these points: firstly, the Ukrainian military has wounded the Russian Army to a degree that it would not be a threat to Nato for many years. There is a case that we should be prepared to provide Ukraine everything they need to push Russian soldiers and mercenaries out of Ukrainian lands as quickly as possible before the Russians can catch up and adapt. It is clear that Nato equipment and intelligence is a generation ahead of “Soviet” capabilities. But will that last forever, especially as China forges closer ties with them?

Secondly, the importance of clear red lines cannot be understated. The absence of them arguably led to this war in the first place. Russia taunts us with nuclear and biological weapons because it knows it terrifies elements of a Western public fed on Netflix, and politicians who require them to vote them back into power in 2024. Nato must make clear to Putin that any use of nuclear or other biological weapons will elicit a conventional response which will render the Russian military impotent for generations. Putin and his henchmen understand this type of threat but believe the “liberal” West does not have the stomach for this type of action. We absolutely must show and mean that we do.

A further point. There are still harbingers of doom who think if Nato were forced to get involved in any fashion there would be a nuclear war. Again, I question this notion. If we said we were going to enforce a No Fly zone around Zaporizhia, for instance, would Putin immediately be able to sell it as justified to press the big red button? There are ways to impact this war in a positive direction militarily without triggering the end of the world.

Far easier, however, to avoid this altogether and win by bleeding Russia dry financially. The West and the global coalition against Russia must properly strangle Putin’s economy in 2023. Some countries, even in the EU, still appear to be spending billions on Russian energy. This must cease, for they continue to finance Russia’s war machine directly. Russia must pay the price for its horrific actions, and be seen to fail.

In short: Putin is trying to draw this war out as long as possible, and there are already flickers of appeasement appearing close to home and from afar. These embers will only grow the longer we allow the war to drag on.  We must be clear that there are some actions Putin might be considering that could lead to Nato’s involvement in the war, and there should be no doubt in the Kremlin about what it would mean if we do.


Colonel (Retd) Hamish de Bretton-Gordon OBE is a former commander of UK & NATO CBRN Forces

………………………..

Selected readers comments:

Martin Hewitt: “In 1939 the world was facing a catastrophe, this country and France recognised it….and addressed it. Here we are in 2023 and we looking down a very similar barrel but no one is prepared to admit it. Be very clear Putin must never be permitted to walk away with any form of victory, even of the face saving kind. If he does walk a away from this with anything resembling a success …..the Chinese will be unstoppable.”

Michael Sommerville: “They say that if we fail to learn from history, we are doomed to repeat it. When Hitler was annexing parts of Europe, everyone was appeasing him. He ignored all promises he had made and so we eventually ended up with WWII when he invaded Poland. 83 years later we are doing the same. If Europe (NATO if you like, but it should have included all of Europe) told Putin to desist in Crimea and taken very positive action to return Crimea to Ukraine in 2014, we would not be having the problems we are having now. Having missed that opportunity, Ukraine should have been flooded with troops and military support from Europe to push Russia back to its borders in February 2022. The opportunity has been lost again because of weak leadership in Europe, particularly from Germany and France being their supposed leaders. All this pontificating is happening again. The Russians have proved themselves to be inferior militarily; both in equipment and manpower training. Putin will continue this war. He will not resort to nuclear weapons because he knows that would be suicide. Sadly, Europe doesn’t have that leadership and courage.”

Scott Glenister :Reply to Michael Sommerville : “Most sane people believe that ‘learning from history’ means not staring another world war, you and your ilk on the other hand..
Defeating Russia means an all out nuclear war, is that what you want?”

Mark West : Reply to Scott Glenister : “Listen “Scott”. No-one is buying your “all out nuclear war” fear-mongering. Didn’t you notice that there is ALREADY a war on – the one Putin started. Your mates “Adam” and the one with the really stupid name are equally unconvincing. No potato.”


Mark West : Reply to Scott Glenister: “Wrong on both counts, but I’ll happily support the West sending lots of nice toys to Ukraine. Hopefully they’ll have sufficient range to hit the troll factories soon – we can only dream.”

Michael Sommerville :Reply to Scott Glenister : “Putin makes threats and the rest of the world thinks he is true to his word, and they cower in the corner. If Russia was to let off a nuclear weapon the retaliation would devastating for Russia.”

John Polenski : “Just been reading a fascinating piece on one of the EU’s less prominent members, Bulgaria. At the beginning of the conflict, Bulgaria was 95 percent dependent on Russian gas, largely due to their previous administration being particularly Kremlin friendly. They could not initially join an embargo on Russia, as large parts of their industry would have closed down overnight. Throughout last year, with help from such diverse sources as the EU, Greece, Turkey and especially the US (which sent LPG tankers almost immediately) they gradually reduced their dependence on Russia. Azerbaijan now supplies one third of Bulgaria’s needs, on a 20 year contract. As of now, start of 2023, the amount of gas Bulgaria buys from Russia is…. zero. A remarkable achievement, and they have said they will never, ever buy from Russia again, for obvious reasons. One by one, the dominoes will start to fall, if countries are resolute enough.”

Jonathan Karmi: “Going by past form, the Internet Research Agency will mobilise twenty trolls to try to discredit this article. It does the same with any article by Colonel Richard Kemp, Dr Jade McGlynn or John Bolton. It’s tiresome and I wish the Telegraph would get its act together to cancel these phony accounts. These comments boards should be for bona fide Telegraph readers only.”

6 comments

  1. He is right. Putlerstan’s economy must be strangled almost to death, just like one of Prigozhin’s victims.
    I am sure there would be a total NFZ by now, were it not for the fact that a piss-ass Marxist runs Nato with the support of covert putler assets France and Germany.
    Nato needs to be overhauled and run by a hard-ass General.
    Either that or the Nato members still with integrity: US-UK-Poland-Canada-The Balts, Slovakia, Czechia,Ukraine, Georgia, Moldova and one or two others must form a new military/trade/political/intel-sharing bloc to handle putlerstan more effectively.

    • I agree. I think Stoltenberg is chosen because he is a decent, but not necessarily very strong and charismatic guy.

      He is a compromise guy, that countries like Germany and France can accept.

      I would like to see a George Patton on that seat, verbally destroying Scholz if he fucks up again.

  2. Russia continues to mass troops in Belarus:

    “https://www.uawire.org/russia-continues-to-amass-troops-in-belarus

  3. Article fails to mention that although gas dependency on mafialand has been greatly diminished, many countries are still importing other goods and have even increased demand, as stated in a previous article from Jan 03.
    https://ukrainetoday.org/2023/01/04/still-filling-putins-coffers/
    Loop holes and incentive to buy ruzzian goods must be thwarted by finally recognizing mafia land as a state sponsor and instigator of terrorism.

    • I actually think the article proves otherwise.
      Take Poland as an example: they paid a lot more to Russia than the years before.

      They weren’t really trading much with Russia, and then the gas price jumped to outer space.

      The fact that the trade volume increased dramatically actually means there wasn’t much trade except for gas.

      I am not proud of the graph, absolutely not. But imagine this: if there is a lot of trade with Russia in 2021, the share of gas is relatively small. So these countries saw a relatively small increase in trade volumes, while those that only bought gas suddenly saw a huge spike.

      Of course I agree that loopholes should be fixed and sanctions should be more strictly enforced, but the graph in the article draws a very biased picture that makes Russia’s situation look a lot better than it really is.

      Now that they no longer provide the EU with oil and gas, most of the trade is gone and Russia is screwed.

      I don’t expect Russia to survive the next couple months.

      • I actually think the article proves otherwise.
        Take Poland as an example: they paid a lot more to Russia than the years before.

        They weren’t really trading much with Russia, and then the gas price jumped to outer space.

        The fact that the trade volume increased dramatically actually means there wasn’t much trade except for gas.

        I am not proud of the graph, absolutely not. But imagine this: if there is a lot of trade with Russia in 2021, the share of gas is relatively small. So these countries saw a relatively small increase in trade volumes, while those that only bought gas suddenly saw a huge spike.

        Of course I agree that loopholes should be fixed and sanctions should be more strictly enforced, but the graph in the article draws a very biased picture that makes Russia’s situation look a lot better than it really is.

        Now that they no longer provide the EU with oil and gas, most of the trade is gone and Russia is screwed.

        I don’t expect Russia to survive the next couple months. Btw, I took the wrong example with Poland, but for example Luxembourg is a better one.

Enter respectful comments here: