
The fastest way to move troops across the battlefield is getting a lot more dangerous
DAVID AXE 15 August 2024 • 4:18pm
When Ukrainian brigades rolled into Russia’s Kursk Oblast in a surprise move on August 6, they were supported from above by a powerful force of small drones.
The presence of attack and surveillance drones over the front line of the Kursk operation wasn’t unusual: drones are everywhere all the time along the line of contact in Russia’s 29-month wider war on Ukraine.
What was unusual was the drones’ set of targets. Before last week, Ukrainian drones strictly targeted Russian troops and vehicles on the ground. But then, on or around August 7, a Ukrainian first-person-view (FPV) drone clutching an explosive payload struck a Russian air force Mil Mi-28 attack helicopter in mid-flight somewhere over Kursk, apparently downing the ’copter and killing its two crew.
It was the first documented air-to-air kill by a drone. That it was a small FPV drone – which normally weighs just a few pounds and demands a high degree of skill from its headset-wearing operator – makes the shoot-down even more impressive.
But it wasn’t a one-time accomplishment. A couple of days later, another Ukrainian FPV drone appears to have struck a Russian Mil Mi-8 transport helicopter apparently somewhere over Kursk. It’s apparent Ukrainian crews have finally mastered the art of ramming a drone into an airborne helicopter.
The air over Ukraine was already pretty dangerous for Russian helicopter crews. Since widening its war in Ukraine in February 2022, the Russian military has lost at least 109 rotorcraft that independent analysts can confirm. They’ve fallen prey to ground-based guns and missiles, mostly – but now Russian helicopter crews must contend with a new threat from FPV drones.
It was obvious this was coming. There was a false alarm just a couple of weeks before the Kursk incursion, when a Russian Mi-8 was destroyed in eastern Ukraine while the helicopter was taking off, reportedly on a medical-evacuation mission. There were numerous fatalities.
Russian sources initially claimed the helicopter was struck by a drone. The claim raised some eyebrows, as the strike may have taken place as far as 10 miles from the front line – far beyond the range of typical FPV drones. Extending a small drone out to 10 miles can require careful coordination of radio signal repeaters on the ground or in the air.
In any event, the main source for that drone shoot-down claim later changed his story – and claimed a ground-launched rocket hit the helicopter.
There’s no mistaking the circumstances of the later strikes on Russian helicopters: there are video feeds from the drone themselves as evidence that the drones at least came within feet or even inches of striking the ’copters before their signals were lost.
Air-to-air drones are helping Ukrainian operators clear the sky over Kursk – of rotorcraft. Don’t expect the tiny drones to start downing fixed-wing aircraft, however. It’s one thing to ram an FPV drone into a helicopter flying a few hundred feet over the ground at a top speed of 100 miles per hour or slower. It’s another to ram a drone into a jet fighter flying hundreds of miles per hour, tens of thousands of feet high.
It’s not that militaries all over the world aren’t working on that problem. They are – but with fast and high-flying drones that are, in essence, pilotless fighters. The downside of this approach to robotic air-to-air combat is the cost: a high-performance drone can cost millions of dollars.
A single FPV drone, on the other hand, costs just a few hundred dollars. That such a cheap drone can, with a sufficiently skilled operator, take down a multi-million-dollar helicopter is a very ominous development for militaries everywhere.
The ability to down helicopters is especially significant in the circumstances of Ukraine’s incursion into Kursk oblast. When a modern army is trying to deal with a deep penetration of this kind, one of its favoured methods will be to move troops quickly and deploy them ahead of the advancing enemy, and the fastest way to move troops on the battlefield is using helicopters. Nato heli-borne troops in Cold War times expected that their main mission would be to move fast, get ahead of Soviet penetrations and contain them using ambush tactics until heavy armoured reinforcements would have time to get in place.
Vladimir Putin’s generals will be frustrated to find that their own helicopter troops have to be very careful in carrying out the mirror image of such operations today as they seek to rush men and weapons into position around the Ukrainian salient – the new Kursk salient of the 21st century, not the 20th century one in which Russia stopped the German panzers dead.
It’s way too soon to predict the helicopter’s extinction as a weapon of war. But that fatal date did inch closer with the first drone-on-’copter shoot-down.

Some interesting comments here from ex or current serving U.K. military:
Peter Jenkins
We should remember that the only reason the Russians beat the Germans around Kursk was that Britain had broken the Enigma code and had the ability to intercept, read, analyse the intelligence and distribute it so that the Russians could see the German plans and counter them. Not many people know this.
Particularly the Russians who still think they did all the fighting in WW2 against the Germans.
This time they are up against a wily foe albeit one with slightly cowardly friends who continue to constrain the use of long range weapons they have given the Ukrainians. Take off those shackles.and the Ukrainians can bring the bear to its knees.
Patrick Steel
I fly FPV drones. They are very small, very fast, very agile and, when flying at full speed into an object, carry a lot of kinetic energy. Also, their Lithium batteries can become incendiary devices very quickly. A drone flying at 180km/hr can literally turn 180 degrees in a 4-5 metres. 0 to 100km/hr for my drones is less than 2 seconds. Flying range about 6 miles before signal loss.
Training is needed, but an already trained regular drone pilot can, if they have the talent for FPV flying (it is not easy, is disorientating and can be very scary), become an effective FPV pilot in around 30 to 40 hours if trained on a readily available PC based simulator such as Tryp FPV or liftoff. These programmed are cheap and readily available. And no, I do not have connections to these companies.
Nigel Gates
100 miles per hour or slower? David, you need to gen up a bit. Modern helos will cruise at 160+ mph, even training helos will comfortably do 130. Hitting a defensively flown low flying helo at speed is a lot more difficult, these guys have done well but the battlefield helicopter is only getting faster and is a long way from dead.
Richard Williams
When a salient such as that at Kursk in the 20th century was on a front hundreds of miles across and a similar depth then moving troops quickly over vast distances might be necessary,
In fact the German one was not stopped by such means but by stealthily placing massive reinforcements in the line and then breaking out with armour in a massive pincer movement organised by Zhukov, aided not a little by the complete order of battle of the German army from Bletchley Park,
In this 21st century salient no more than a few miles across and deep, it might have been useful to deploy troops rapidly and could have been achieved if the Russians weren’t such an organisational mess,
The mix of FSB border control, internal troops, and the regular army with no overall commander or direction is so typical.
Truck convoys can easily be routed by similar drones, and had there been a cohesive armoured units the response might have been far more assured,
It may not have been the lack of speed that caused the rapid withdrawal, but the hopeless chain of command and lack of flexibility.
If the Ukrainians had the ability to take out more distant targets such as bridges and even air equality rather than supremacy, the Russians might now be reeling with much of Kursk ad Belgorod no longer a launch pad for glide bombs.
FPV drones taking down helicopters is noteworthy in that it may prevent ground attacks from gun ships but they certainly travel far faster than 100MPH and more than 100 ft up.
Canute Turner
They are only vulnerable to small drone attack when landing and taking off.
Ross McInnes
Reply to Canute Turner
Take out the the tail rotor.
Richard Williams
Reply to Ross McInnes
If its 1000 ft up and travelling at 200MPH a drone won’t do it.
Patrick Steel
Reply to Richard Williams
A DJI FPV would easily do it, especially if coming from direct ahead or underneath. This drone will do 143km/hr using standard firmware, but if hacked, can easily reach 180km/hr. Hacking software can be bought legally straight off the internet. However, if used, it does void the drone warranty. Still, I don’t suppose that worries the Ukrainians! Hacking software can be downloaded for around 15 pounds.
Most full on racing drone will easily top 270km/hr but have limited battery life. Still, if close enough, and sucked into an intake, they will cause serious damage.
My DJI FPV weighs around 800 grammes. When travelling at 140km/hr, it will cause serious damage to whatever it hits. Throw in its lithium battery, and you have a very dangerous projectile.
As for height. It is limited by manufacturers to around 500 metres, but can easily get to 5000 feet by hacking. Range is about 6 miles before signal loss, but buy a cheap signal booster and only battery life comes into play.
FPV drones are very fast, very agile (140km/hr 180 degree turns in less than 5 mtrs), very cheap and deadly when striking something. They can skim the ground or fly high enough to be a problem.
Training simulators are cheap (10-15 pounds) and readily available (TRYP FPV and Liftoff.). An experienced normal drone pilot can, if they have talent, be trained on FPV flying in around 30 to 40 hours. However, its not easy and actually quite disorientating and scary. That said, it can be done by anyone who has some basic competence. I am 70 years old and fly full acrobatic “freestyle” FPV at these speeds.
When I was in the RAF operating surface to air missiles, we went for targets either flying parallel to us or coming towards us, not going away.
Finally, Helicopters have to slow down to drop troops.
Ian Biddle
I think they said something similar about tanks when the first few of those were destroyed by anti-tank guns.
James Stythe
Reply to Ian Biddle
And they were right, as the Russians found when they tried to take Kiev in ‘22. One of the major factors in Russia’s defeat in Afghanistan, before drones were even a thing, was the repeated shoot downs of their helicopters by (CIA provided) Stinger missiles. The Russians then took to ground movement only, whereas ironically because the Taliban didn’t have Stingers but they did use IEDs, ISAF found heliborne movement much safer. I guess modern helicopters are faster and better armoured so the modern version of Stingers, whatever they are called are less effective but drones..? I’d be seriously worried in a military helicopter. I recall a wise military airman reminding me that a fixed wing aircraft kind of wants to fly, because of its design, like a bird but a helicopter really doesn’t!
James Bulloch
Drones, UAVs and missiles are beginning to merge into a super-class, with autonomous flight activity, route selection and AI targeting all technically possible. Some loitering munitions can spend several hours cruising about within a geographical envelope, looking for a target. If it isn’t required to report back over some form of radio data link, it can be electronically silent and use INS guidance. A small swarm of a dozen could effectively neutralise air defence systems in a area, with survivors programmed to hone in on any missile or radar laid guns firing at them. Or they could be programmed to return to a friendly area and be recovered by parachute, for refuelling and re-use.
All technically feasible. Whether it’s a good thing or not is a different argument.
Interesting posts.
But, some of those skeptics about drones vs choppers seem to have missed the light speed development of drones in this war. If you compare the drones now to just two and a half years ago, this should give them an idea that downing even choppers that are flying at speed and altitude should be possible. I’m not saying easy, but possible.
A quick look showed me that the current fastest camera drone does around 350 km/h … that’s around 217 mph! Not many choppers fly that fast.
I agree with the Ukrainian serviceman in the clip.
The only thing stopping the Ukrainians from taking and holding a parcel of land of equal size to what the putinaZis are squatting on is a) abysmal lack of support from the allies and b) insufficient manpower.
Addressing issue b) : surely it is time for the defenders to hire mercs? Ten divisions worth.
Plus : Ukraine badly need that $350 bn of putinaZi cash. They can buy their way out of trouble and secure their land with that amount.
No matter what Ukraine does, or promises, no matter what lion-like courage it shows to the world, it cannot encourage the discouraged from getting courage. Juveniles would call Biden, Scholz, and the others pussies. Their pathetic cowardice is endangering not only Ukraine, but the entire free world.