23 JUNE 2024


Alexander Dobrindt, the Chairman of the Bavarian opposition Christian Social Union (CSU) party in the German Bundestag, has called for the expulsion of unemployed Ukrainian refugees from Germany.
Source: Dobrindt in an interview with German tabloid Bild, cited by ZDF, as reported by European Pravda
Details: Dobrindt believes that Ukrainian refugees should be expelled from Germany if they don’t get a job.
“After more than two years after the outbreak of the war, the principle should now be applied: get a job in Germany or return to the safe areas of western Ukraine,” he said.
The opposition politician also criticised the fact that too many people in Germany receive social assistance at the expense of taxpayers’ money.
“We need stronger cooperation commitments for asylum seekers when it comes to employment. There should be a job offer, and this should be part of the integration service,” Dobrindt said.
The oppositionist’s demand was sharply criticised by representatives of the government coalition. Dirk Wiese, Deputy Leader of Chancellor Scholz’s Social Democrats parliamentary faction, told Bild that the CSU should be ashamed of such demands and “remove the letter ‘C’ from its name, which stands for ‘Christian’, for once and for all”.
“Putin continues to bomb targets across Ukraine. Now Dobrindt also wants to send back women and children who may have already lost their parents at the front,” he said.
Meanwhile, Omid Nouripour, leader of the Green Party, which is also part of the government coalition, also criticised Dobrindt’s proposal.
“Insinuations that Ukrainians come to us for social assistance do not recognise the horror of Putin’s war,” he said.
Earlier, it was reported that the Jobturbo programme for the accelerated integration of Ukrainians into the German labour market managed to attract about 33,000 people, six times less than the German government expected.
German Federal Minister of Labour Hubertus Heil called on employers to hire Ukrainian refugees who have not yet mastered the German language at the proper level but have basic knowledge of it.
Background:
The day before, a number of politicians in Germany called for the cancellation of standard unemployment benefits for Ukrainian refugees in the country, the so-called “money for citizens” (Bürgergeld).
Support UP or become our patron!
https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2024/06/23/7462133

This measure can be a hot potato for the ruling coalition parties. The constant gains by extremist parties are largely due to Germany’s lax immigration/asylum laws, seeing the country flooded with people from all corners of the globe. This is causing a constant increase of social tensions.
Although Ukraine is still in a terrible war, at least the Ukrainian males should be sent back to Ukraine. Not so much for the country’s military, but for its economy. Ukraine is suffering from an acute labor shortage.
It is ridiculous having tens of thousands or even hundreds of thousands of healthy, skilled Ukrainian men sitting around uselessly in Europe letting their country down!
Having said that, if such a measure should come to pass (fat chance), then the same should go for ALL asylum seekers, not only Ukrainian ones.
With immigration, I think it is important not to generalize. Sending all men back to Ukraine? Okay, but what about those unfit for duty for medical reasons or veterans? Families that had to incur casualties leaving the care for young children to a male.
I think there are many cases in which it wouldn’t make sense to send people back which I didn’t even think about.
Also, Ukraine doesn’t really have the means to take care of the millions of refugees that have lost their homes, their jobs and may suffer from mental and physical problems.
As a Dutchman, I do think there are too many draft dodgers and I often see Ukrainian men driving in cars of which I cannot even dream about ever affording them. I live next to a very expensive street and there are two luxury cars with Ukrainian license plates there.
I went to the Ukraine – Slovakia soccer match in Germany and I was quite surprised by the number of Ukrainian men and the value of their cars.
I do acknowledge there is a problem, but I think we shouldn’t go for too rough and untargeted measures as these may create more problems than they actually solve. I think some micromanagement is needed here.
Sending back a guy from the Netherlands that is taking care for orphans might not be in Ukraine’s best interest.
^yellow man
You seem to have misunderstood my post, or maybe I didn’t elaborate enough on what I meant. Of course, there are special situations in which it’s not a good idea to send a male back to Ukraine. What I meant was that every able-bodied male should be sent back, who isn’t the sole parent to a child or children or whatever else might be inhumane. As you’ve pointed out, there are plenty of Ukrainian men who are in Europe that could and should be in their country instead of living the easy life, letting everyone else left behind to fight for Ukraine and work their asses off to support the economy.
I didn’t really meant it critique on your comment, as I have no doubt you wouldn’t send a wounded Ukrainian soldier or a single parent to Ukraine, more as a general remark that any policies regarding Ukrainian refugees should take individual stories into account.
I am mostly targeting this populist CDU guy that proposes some harsh measures without a lot of thought.
He is pretending that Ukrainians are in Germany just for fun and draining the treasury to appeal to some AfD-minded people to get some voters back.
There is also some hypocrisy in what this ass hole is saying. He complains about people not working in Germany.
I think in the most ideal situation, Ukrainians that are unable to work because they are wounded, unfit for work or old are in Germany for protection.
Those that are able to take care of themselves shouldn’t be in Germany.
Having a lot of Ukrainians in Germany that do not work actually means they are getting the right people.
When they work they are seen as draft lodgers going to Germany for funsies, when they don’t they are seen as some parasites.
The job of populist politicians isn’t hard, they will always find a way to shit on Ukrainian refugees no matter who they are or what they do.
My own experience with Ukrainian refugees (only women though, I don’t know any male refugees) is that they are generally praised for their incredible work ethic despite all the psychological trauma and that they learn very fast.
^yellow man
I don’t think that he meant those who are wounded, old, or otherwise not able to work. I’m sure that you are not the only person in Europe who sees Ukrainian men driving fat, expensive vehicles and asks him or herself, what the hell? Germany will not send anyone back that is real need for asylum, I’m sure.
Having said that, I do hope that the ones who are mentally and physically fit, must be returned to Ukraine, and the sooner it happens, the better for Germany AND for Ukraine.
I agree with you, but I don’t trust the CDU guy.
Somehow I feel he doesn’t care about Ukrainians and only want to look like a guy tough on migrants to appeal to some far-right voters.
The CDU is in the sewer and is trying to be a AfD-light to become relevant again.
^Ernie’s best friend