Forced Ukraine to finance Russian army: Kyiv judge suspected of treason

Tanya Polyakovskaya17:16, 18.01.25

In 2012, the judge granted the Russian Defense Ministry’s claims and groundlessly ordered the Ukrainian state to pay the plaintiff $405.5 million, the State Bureau of Investigation says.

The State Bureau of Investigation continues to sort out the legacy of Viktor Yanukovych . Today, a notice of suspicion was given to the current judge of the Kyiv City Commercial Court for a decision he made in the interests of the Russian Ministry of Defense. As noted in a statement on the SBI website , not only the judge, but also the former top leadership of the state received suspicion in the case.

“It has been established that back in 2011, the aggressor country involved the then president, prime minister of Ukraine and judge of the Kyiv Commercial Court, as well as heads of various levels of the judicial system, in subversive activities against Ukraine,” the report says.

It is noted that the Russian leadership has developed a plan according to which the aggressor’s defense capability and armed forces will be financed from the State Budget of Ukraine under the guise of fulfilling the decision of the Kyiv Commercial Court to pay off a non-existent debt.

“For this purpose, in 2011, the Russian Defense Minister approached the Ukrainian leadership with a letter asking for assistance in paying off the debt of one of the business entities in the amount of 405.5 million US dollars for natural gas supplied back in 1996-1997,” the State Bureau of Investigation said.

It is emphasized that Ukraine had nothing to do with the debt of the commercial enterprise and could not be held responsible for it. However, the former leadership of the country in 2011 began to emphasize in the media that Ukraine should pay the specified amount to the Russian Ministry of Defense.

In addition, a letter was prepared to the Security Service of Ukraine with a request to bring the head of the enterprise to criminal responsibility for allegedly shifting this debt onto the state.

“In an attempt to artificially create grounds for direct financing of the Russian Defense Ministry at the expense of the Ukrainian state budget, officials involved the leadership of the judicial system and a judge of the Kyiv Commercial Court to collect 405.5 million US dollars in favor of the Russian Federation based on an unlawful court decision,” the State Bureau of Investigation noted.

Thus, according to the scheme developed by the defendants, in August 2012, the Russian Ministry of Defense filed a lawsuit in the Kyiv Commercial Court against the Cabinet of Ministers of Ukraine to recover more than 3 billion UAH from the state budget.

“The Russians were counting on the fact that back in 2004, the then Prime Minister, and later the President of Ukraine, promised to assist them in the execution of these court decisions. However, due to the absence of contractual legal relations between the plaintiff and the defendant, the judge had to refuse to open proceedings on the case,” the report says.

Moreover, the Russian Defense Ministry did not attach any evidence to the lawsuit to prove why Ukraine should pay this debt. However, the judge of the Commercial Court “made an illegal ruling and shifted the burden of collecting and presenting evidence in the case to the defendant.”

According to this resolution, the Cabinet of Ministers provided copies of correspondence between the heads of the governments of Ukraine and Russia in 1996. They were dated before the business entity concluded the agreement under which the debt arose, so these letters could not be evidence of either the existence of the debt or its shifting to Ukraine, the State Bureau of Investigation noted. In addition, the originals of these letters never existed, but the court ignored this fact.

“Despite the expiration of the statute of limitations and the absence of state guarantees for the enterprise’s debts, as well as the absence of evidence of the very fact of the existence in 2012 of the enterprise’s debt under contracts from 1996-1997, the judge satisfied the claim of the Russian Defense Ministry and ruled to collect more than UAH 3.1 billion from any account of the State Budget of Ukraine in favor of the Russian Federation,” the State Bureau of Investigation noted.

In pursuance of this illegal court decision, part of the funds were collected from Ukraine in favor of Russia. “After the start of the Russian Federation’s aggression against our country and the change of the state leadership, another judge of the Commercial Court overturned this illegal decision in 2014, but it was not possible to return the money that was groundlessly collected in the interests of Russia. According to the investigation, these funds went to finance the so-called SVO,” the report says.

Thus, the actions of the suspects were qualified under Part 2 of Article 28, Part 1 of Article 111 of the Criminal Code of Ukraine as high treason committed by prior conspiracy by a group of persons. The maximum punishment is 15 years of imprisonment.

A petition was also signed to the High Council of Justice to remove this judge from the judiciary and to grant consent for detention.

(C)UNIAN 2025

Enter respectful comments here: