
Donald Trump’s vice presidential pick is very critical of supporting Ukraine; POLITICO took a look at how his claims stack up.

J.D. Vance has seized on Ukraine as one of his signature foreign policy issues. | Joe Raedle/Getty Images
JULY 16, 2024
KYIV — J.D. Vance has a lot to say about Ukraine, which is why Kyiv froze when Donald Trump chose the Ohio senator to be his running mate on Monday.
Just after Russia invaded Ukraine in February 2022, Vance, then a candidate for U.S. Senate, said: “I gotta be honest with you, I don’t really care what happens to Ukraine one way or another.”
Starting from those first days of fighting, Vance has seized on Ukraine as one of his signature foreign policy issues. His isolationist position differentiates him from more conventional Republicans and also cements his ties with Trump’s MAGA adherents.
Vance has been hammering home his views on Ukraine ever since. POLITICO took a look at how they stack up:
Ukraine is corrupt
The claim
“We’re getting easily half a trillion dollars in the hole for the Ukraine conflict … Why? So that one of the Zelenskyy’s ministers can buy a bigger yacht?” he said in an interview with former Trump strategist Steve Bannon last year.
“I admire the brave Ukrainians … but let’s not mistake the courage of Ukrainian troops on the ground with the fact that they have the most corrupt leadership and government in Europe and maybe the most corrupt leadership anywhere in the world,” Vance said in a speech at the Heritage Foundation.
The reality
Ukraine is quite corrupt, despite efforts by the government to clean up the country. In Transparency International’s annual Corruption Perceptions Index, Ukraine ranks 104th out of 180 countries with a score of 36 out of 100 points, where 0 means highly corrupt.
In 2014, the year Russia annexed Crimea and started the war in eastern Ukraine, Ukraine had a significantly worse score of 26. That’s actually Russia’s score this year; it ranks 144th out of 180 countries — much worse than Ukraine. The United States has a score of 69 and ranks 24 out of 144 countries — better than both Russia and Ukraine but behind much of Western Europe.
And about the yachts. Rumors that Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy has bought yachts is a Russian disinformation plot that has been picked up by members of the U.S. Congress.
Ukraine doesn’t account for donated weapons
The claim
Ukraine isn’t properly accounting for $1 billion out of $1.7 billion in weapons incorporating sensitive technology, according to a Senate memo sent by Vance in January that quotes a Pentagon watchdog report.
The reality
In 2022, Ukraine established a parliamentary commission to control donated Western weapons. “Ukraine files reports on how we use American weapons every quarter, which brigades have U.S. weapons and how many and of course what was lost in battle,” Oleksandra Ustinova, the head of the commission, told POLITICO.
The U.S. also keeps an eye on weapons. The report that Vance cited actually said that Americans, not Ukrainians, failed to adequately track roughly $1 billion of Javelin and Stinger missiles, night vision devices, and other monitoring devices.
“That report was painful to us and that number was caught and used by many Ukraine aid opposers,” she said, adding that the report by Pentagon-appointed Robert Storch “later explained everything.”

The West cannot outproduce Russia in weapons
The claim
“The amount of munitions that we can send to Ukraine right now is very limited not by American will, or money, but by American manufacturing capacity,” Vance said during the Munich Security Conference.
The reality
He has a point. Russia is producing about 3 million artillery shells a year, according to a NATO estimate. That’s about three times more than the West. However, Western production is ramping up. By 2026, the European Commission estimates the EU will be producing 2 million shells a year. The U.S. aims to produce about 80,000 a month by the end of this year.
Military aid to Ukraine is harming the U.S. economy
The claim
In an April speech, Vance complained about a new U.S. defense spending bill, saying: “While it does invest some in critical manufacturing of American weapons, it sends those weapons overseas faster than it even replenishes them. This is not a bill to rebuild the defense industrial base. This is a bill to further extend this country.”
In letter to the Washington Post, he said: “The fact that weapons of war are made in America does not justify sending them abroad, and a $100 billion foreign aid package is not pro-worker manufacturing policy. It undermines our national security by exhausting critical resources on a strategic quagmire.”
The reality
“Most U.S. contributions go to military aid, including weapons and equipment made by American defense contractors who employ communities across the country. When the United States spends money to purchase military equipment as part of an international aid package, the material may go overseas, but the money and jobs stay in America,” said a report by the German Marshall Fund of the U.S.
Ukraine has too few soldiers
The claim
“Ukraine needs more soldiers than it can field, even with draconian conscription policies,” Vance wrote in an op-ed for The New York Times.
The reality
True. Ukraine, with a population of less than 40 million, cannot compete with Russia’s 143 million. Ukraine has about 900,000 active soldiers against 1.4 million Russians, according to Statista.
Under pressure from its allies, Ukraine updated its mobilization law to draft a larger pool of men. However, many potential recruits have fled the country and Kyiv has asked other countries to help motivate Ukrainians living abroad to join the army.
Ukraine now has 14 brigades waiting to rotate exhausted frontline troops, but those brigades still are not properly armed due to delays in Western aid, Zelenskyy said.
Ukraine can’t win the war
The claim
“The American people will not tolerate another endless war and neither will I,” Vance said earlier this year when Congress was approving about $61 billion in military aid for Ukraine, a measure he opposed.
The reality
That’s the big unknown. Ukraine has done better than almost anyone expected in fending off Russia’s invasion, but it’s an open question if it can win the war.
How Kyiv is responding to Vance
Officials in Kyiv prefer to keep their opinions on Trump and his VP pick to themselves.
“It’s not our business who they choose,” one official close to the president’s office said.
Zelenskyy said he is ready to work with any U.S. administration.
Senior Ukrainian officials console themselves that the vice president’s role is relatively modest in setting U.S. policy.
Then there’s Vance’s political malleability; he went from comparing Trump to Hitler to becoming his running mate. “This means that his views may change on international issues as well,” Oleksandr Merezhko, the head of Ukraine’s parliamentary foreign relations committee, told POLITICO.
Finally, there is hope in Kyiv that the anti-Ukraine rhetoric is just part of the campaign battle, and may not reflect post-election policy.
“Even if Trump becomes the new president, due to objective foreign policy reality he will be forced to pursue the same policy as Biden,” said Merezhko. “As for Vance, if Trump wins, we’ll have to patiently make the appropriate persuasive arguments.”
He recognized that for Vance, “the interests of the United States come first. So, it is necessary to prove to him that supporting Ukraine fully corresponds to the interests of the United States … We have only one enemy — Russia. And we don’t need to make enemies of Trumpists.”

“Even if Trump becomes the new president, due to objective foreign policy reality he will be forced to pursue the same policy as Biden,”
Possible, but seems extremely unlikely, to put it mildly.
“Ukraine has done better than almost anyone expected in fending off Russia’s invasion, but it’s an open question if it can win the war.”
Without US support it is extremely unlikely.
“Ukraine has too few soldiers.”
“True. Ukraine, with a population of less than 40 million, cannot compete with Russia’s 143 million. Ukraine has about 900,000 active soldiers against 1.4 million Russians, according to Statista.”
An unarguable fact. To return Ukraine to its legal borders; and hold them, will take 2 million combat troops.
To prevent further incursions Ukraine will need the full restoration of its nuclear deterrent.
Funding : putinaZi sequester funds, plus exploitation rights to Ukraine’s mineral resources to its allies.
Btw, does the west, even including the Trumpkov-Vanskov shitshow, really want putler to get Ukraine’s rare earths, white hydrogen, oil, gas/shale gas, uranium and oil?
From a geopolitical standpoint, Vance is a moron. He is not a good choice for either the US or the world.