Britain is sending the right tanks to Ukraine

COMMENT

Firepower, protection, mobility, and ability to fight at night set modern Western tanks way above what’s left of the Russian tank fleet

Hamish de Bretton-Gordon

18 January 2023 •

A British Challenger 2

No sooner did the long-awaited news break that Britain would be sending Challenger 2 (CR2) tanks to Ukraine, when some began to argue we were sending them the wrong tanks. On Monday, in this paper, it was suggested we should prioritise getting hold of the 400 or so Challenger 1s (CR1) being made obsolete by Jordan. It’s an interesting idea – but wrong.

With many thousands of hours in both CR1 and CR2, I judge opting for CR1s a distraction.  What has been successful in Ukraine is modern Western weaponry, like NLAW and HIMARS.  CR1 is in effect a Chieftain tank – 1950’s technology – with a decent engine and Chobham armour, the forerunner of the “secret” and impenetrable Dorchester armour. CR2 can fire accurately on the move and at night, critical for ‘shock action’ to get behind Russian defences, something CR1 and most of the Russian tanks cannot do.

Crucial to getting Ukraine ready for an armoured thrust to encircle enemy forces is converting their tank crews to be able to use Western tanks. This is far easier to do for CR2s than CR1s. I converted from Chieftain to CR1 and from CR1 to CR2, so have a bit of experience here. Then, as second in command of the 2nd Royal Tank Regiment, I converted 500 tank soldiers from CR1 to CR2. This was straightforward, and my own conversion took less than a day. Whilst I’m oversimplifying it, CR2 is essentially PlayStation technology for firing the gun and using the tank; so easy to assimilate for anybody under 30, which I expect most Ukrainian tank crews are. In comparison, CR1 is steam-driven gunnery, not intuitive; the fire control box is down on your right-hand side, and you need to be a contortionist to use it, whilst your head is in the gunsight tracking targets.

From a maintenance perspective, by contrast, I found the CR2 hugely reliable. My last experience in a CR2 was on a major exercise in Canada where my tank went 2,500 miles without a problem. Many of the systems in a CR2 are plug and play, with major components like engines being replaced in short order if problems arise – little challenge, I expect, for Ukrainian mechanics. The UK has been supporting a battle group of CR2s in Estonia for some time, so logistic lines are in place across Europe, and we still have significant CR2 infrastructure in Germany.  Allied to this is a vast tank training area in Poland – which many of us have spent too much time at! – but may be ideal to familiarise Ukrainian tanks crews with CR2 fire and manoeuvre capabilities.

It is the firepower, protection, mobility, and ability to fight at night which sets modern Western tanks way above what’s left of the Russian tank fleet and perhaps CR1. The ability to fire on the move, in the dark (due to our effective thermal sights) will allow the Ukrainian armour, supported by infantry in high mobility Bradley vehicles and by AS90 and other guns to get behind the Russians, could be transformative. The Russians are in static defence and their conscripts are fighting a First World War type entrenched slugging match which will be overwhelmed by this force. Even the much-vaunted criminals in the Wagner Group will be likely crushed by this weight of armour.

I applaud the veritable Ben Wallace, once a trooper in the Scots Dragoon Guards, for leading the cavalry charge to provide decisive capability to Ukraine. But I would go further and not only give the Ukrainians a small number of CR2s, but to empty our tank sheds of them entirely. It will take the Russians five to seven years to rebuild their tank fleet and it is a chance for us to do similar, perhaps with a completely new tank rather than just an upgrade of an old one. Is now not the time to be thinking boldly? 

In the meantime, we must hope that the CR2s push Europe into action. If the Germans still won’t lean into the fight, they must allow the Finns and Poles to donate their Leopards to join our Challengers. The early models of both were designed to defeat Soviet armour and prevent invasion. They are now going to realise this task, thanks to the forward-leaning British Government. But rather than just 14 tanks we should be sending all those which are not currently needed. CR2 cannot destroy Russian armour sitting in a tank shed in Tidworth and will be of little use in the future if Russia prevails in its illegal invasion of Ukraine.


Col Hamish de Bretton-Gordon OBE is a former commander of the 1st Royal Tank Regiment

6 comments

  1. Great article from Hamish, with lots of solid info. I especially liked : “CR2 is essentially PlayStation technology for firing the gun and using the tank; so easy to assimilate for anybody under 30, which I expect most Ukrainian tank crews are.”
    And: “I would go further and not only give the Ukrainians a small number of CR2s, but to empty our tank sheds of them entirely.”
    If we do that and the Ukrainians get the Leopards, Ukraine will win quicker than previously thought.
    Gen Zaluzhnyi wanted 300 modern tanks. Let’s give him more, plus long range missiles, so that for every demonic war crime and child murder committed by putler, the consequences will be twice as bad for the cauldron of devilry.

  2. Are Russians today incapable of coherent speech?

    Russia says UK’s Challenger 2 tanks heading to Ukraine ‘will burn just like the rest’…

    What they are really thinking is ‘UK’s Challenger 2 tanks will burn (us alive) just like the rest (of modern weapons)’. I couldn’t stand to be Russian and unable to express myself.

    I greatly respect the UK now as I never have before. In comparison, Russian culture is like a toilet that needs to be washed.

    • We’ve been dealing with mafia land for almost exactly 9 years now, and we’ve learned that they not only have serious issues with speech impediment, but lack basic knowledge in geography and mathematics and are especially terrible at history. Their personal hygiene and table manners are also not the best.

  3. A very good article that sheds some light on the Challenger 2 tank and its capabilities, and this from someone who knows what he’s talking about.
    Yes, it would be great to see enough of them getting to Ukraine to form at least a tank regiment. I think this would suffice to punch a nice hole into the cockroach lines, with the help of other modern Western gear.

  4. Yes Russia they are terrible tanks. Almost as bad as Abrams.

    There is no need to buy additional drones from Iran or to mobilise, you can easily destroy these tanks with shovels or Mosin rifles.

    I wouldn’t worry if I were Shoigu or Putin, as Challenger 2 tanks are even easier to destroy than HIMARS of which the Russian army destroyed 184 out of the 20 HIMARS delivered to Ukraine.

Enter respectful comments here: