BREAKING: “Putin has Lost the War” and Failed in all His Objectives

Silicon Wafers

2025-10-06 | Silicon Wafers 021 | Ukraine is winning the war. That’s the thesis explored in Yuval Noah Harari’s recent FT essay. But is it true? And what does “winning” mean in a war of attrition and existential stakes? We’ll unpack Harari’s claims and examine what experts and commentators think about it. Harari’s Case — “Why Ukraine Is Winning the War”

In Why Ukraine Is Winning the War (FT, last week) Harari stakes a bold claim: the war is already decided in Ukraine’s favor, because Russia has failed to achieve its principal aims. (Financial Times)

He frames winning not as capturing territory but meeting political objectives. In his words:
“War is won by the side that achieves its political aims. And in Ukraine, it is already clear that Putin has failed to achieve his chief war aim …” (Financial Times)
———-

2 comments

  1. On Feb 28, 2022, when the world had written Ukraine off, Yuval Noah Harari wrote in The Guardian :

    “We can all be inspired to dare to do something, whether it is make a donation, welcome refugees, or help with the struggle online. The war in Ukraine will shape the future of the entire world. If tyranny and aggression are allowed to win, we will all suffer the consequences. There is no point to remain just observers. It’s time to stand up and be counted.

    Unfortunately, this war is likely to be long-lasting. Taking different forms, it may well continue for years. But the most important issue has already been decided. The last few days have proved to the entire world that Ukraine is a very real nation, that Ukrainians are a very real people, and that they definitely don’t want to live under a new Russian empire. The main question left open is how long it will take for this message to penetrate the Kremlin’s thick walls.”

    Pretty close to the mark eh?

  2. I agree 100% with what JF, OS and DW. P say about Kyiv Of Mine. It is brilliant and very moving indeed.

Enter respectful comments here: