A Russian Commander Neglected To Order Artillery Support For His Troops. The ‘Doomed To Fail’ Assault Was A Bloodbath.

The wounded Russian survivors hid in a treeline for at least five days.

Nov 8, 2024

10th Mountain Brigade capture

A direct attack on an entrenched enemy is dangerous. A direct attack without any artillery support is practically suicidal, as Russian troops learned on Saturday.

“Why do these fools in uniform still get to decide who lives and who dies?” one Russian blogger moaned in a missive translated by the Estonian analyst WarTranslated. The blogger was referring to the disastrous Saturday assault by the Russian 123rd Motor Rifle Brigade on positions held by the Ukrainian 10th Mountain Assault Brigade around Bilohorivka in eastern Ukraine’s Donetsk Oblast.

The 10th Mountain Brigade was ready and waiting when four Russian battalions attacked, each with potentially dozens of vehicles. Normally a Russian commander would order his supporting artillery to bombard a Ukrainian position ahead of an attack in order to suppress the defenders. For some reason, the 123rd Motor Rifle Brigade’s commander did no such thing.

“An unprepared attack without accompanying support was doomed to fail,” the blogger wrote. Sure enough, the Ukrainians blasted the approaching Russian BMP fighting vehicles and up-armored turtle tanks with Stugna-P anti-tank missiles and explosive drones, leaving at least eight vehicles wrecked or abandoned along the main road threading from Bilohorivka to Vyimka.

Those eight struck vehicles are just the ones the 10th Mountain Brigade caught on camera. There may be many more Russian losses. “We suffered heavy losses in tanks and infantry fighting vehicles,” the blogger complained, “with many soldiers killed and even more wounded.”

Five days later, the wounded survivors of the failed assault were reportedly still lying in a nearby treeline, awaiting evacuation that showed no sign of coming. “It’s the third year of the special operation, yet commanders continue to lie and make mistakes, disregarding the lives of their soldiers,” the blogger wrote.

A year after launching a powerful counteroffensive all along the 800-mile front line of the wider war, Russian forces are advancing along several key axis. But Russian gains along the axis between Bilohorivka and Vyimka have been minimal: a couple of miles, at most.

If the recent Russian assault is any indication, poor leadership might be the main reason the Russians are underperforming in this sector. And there are few prospects for positive changes in the command structure of the 123rd Motor Rifle Brigade. The unit’s commanders “are not afraid of punishment,” the blogger pointed out.

Follow me on Twitter. Check out my website or some of my other work here. Send me a secure tip. 

Sources:

1. Ukraine Control Map

2. 10th Mountain Assault Brigade via Moklasen

3. WarTranslated

David Axe

https://www.forbes.com/sites/davidaxe/2024/11/08/a-russian-commander-neglected-to-order-artillery-support-for-his-troops-the-doomed-to-fail-assault-was-a-bloodbath/?ss=aerospace-defense

3 comments

  1. “A Russian Commander Neglected To Order Artillery Support For His Troops.”

    Either gross incompetence, which is the norm in the cockroach army, or there simply was no artillery available.

Enter respectful comments here: