Jul 15, 2023


ARIS MESSINIS/AFP via Getty Images
- A Russian general fired for raising concerns revealed clues about the state of the artillery duels in Ukraine.
- He said Russia is struggling to knock out Ukrainian artillery while Russian forces suffer “mass deaths.”
- The counter-battery fight is critical in the counteroffensive, and it looks like Ukraine has an edge.
Before he was sacked, a Russian general raised concerns about the dire situation his men are facing in a key sector of the front. After he was fired, he revealed publicly that Ukraine is bloodying his forces in an important fight, the artillery battle.
In an audio message shared online, Maj. Gen. Ivan Popov said he brought concerns about “the lack of counter-battery combat, the absence of artillery reconnaissance stations and the mass deaths and injuries of our brothers in enemy artillery fire” up to “the highest level” of the Russian military.
Artillery is one of the Ukrainian military’s most important weapons as its soldiers run a deadly gauntlet of minefields and dug-in enemy positions executing a counteroffensive push. Artillery is essential for eliminating Russian guns able to waylay assault columns and for targeting Russian defensive lines to kill and disorient troops stationed there.
Popov is the former commanding officer of the 58th Combined Arms Army, which is battling an ongoing Ukrainian offensive in the Zaporizhzhia region, a front-line sector where Ukrainian forces have been pressing the Russian lines hard, and his concerns add to growing evidence that Ukraine seems to have an edge in the artillery duel in the south.
Rather than addressing his concerns, military leaders relieved Popov of his command. The general said in response to his dismissal that while his army fought the Ukrainians, “our senior commander hit us from the rear, treacherously and vilely decapitating the army at the most difficult and tense moment.”
A key element of the counteroffensive in its early stages is the counter-battery fight, which involves trying to eliminate an enemy’s indirect fire assets, such as mortars and artillery, that can shatter assaults on Russian positions. In this fight, Ukraine relies heavily on rocket artillery systems like the High Mobility Artillery Rocket Systems, or HIMARS, or howitzers like the 155 mm M777s.
As Jack Watling, a Royal United Services Institute land warfare expert, assessed early on in the Ukrainian counteroffensive, “there is an intense counterbattery duel being fought, with both sides trying to strike each other’s logistics, command and control, reconnaissance, and artillery systems.”
These types of operations can be a challenge for an army if it advances beyond the reach of its available systems, still a possibility for Ukraine, or if it finds itself outgunned, a problem Kyiv’s forces have faced alongside ammunition concerns.
Gen. Valery Zaluzhny, the top officer in Ukraine’s armed forces, said in a recent interview with The Washington Post that his forces are at times being outshot tenfold in the artillery battle.
Where the Ukrainians do have an advantage, as Can Kasapoğlu, a non-resident senior fellow at the Hudson Institute, notes, is in its modern artillery “kill chain.”
This system is “supported by counter-battery radars and spotter drones,” tools suited to finding Russian assets, “as well as better fire-support systems,” essentially better weapons, “that came from NATO nations’ generous military assistance packages,” he wrote in commentary this week.
The US has provided Ukraine with AN/TPQ-36 radar systems designed to detect incoming mortar, rocket, and artillery fire and identify where it was fired from, facilitating follow-on counter-battery fire operations.
The Ukrainian armed forces are also equipped with HIMARS firing Guided Multiple Launch Rocket Systems (GMLRS) and M777 artillery systems that have proved particularly effective since their deliveries last year.
And, although Ukraine has had to conserve ammo due to dwindling stockpiles of 155 mm artillery shells both at home and among Western partners, including the US, which has provided millions of shells, the country is now receiving cluster munitions.
Dual-purpose improved conventional munitions, or DPICMS, do more damage across a larger area than standard unitary artillery shells by releasing bomblets, or submunitions.
“Artillery is at the core of this conflict,” White House National Security Adviser Jake Sullivan said last Friday, adding that “Ukraine is firing thousands of rounds a day.” With cluster munitions, it can do more damage while expending less ammunition, taking some of the pressure off Ukraine while making Russia’s problems worse.

AP Photo/Libkos
As a recent Forbes analysis citing open-source intelligence reporting found, since the Ukrainian counteroffensive began, Russia has lost four artillery pieces for every one that Ukraine has lost, significantly eroding what was once an advantage in total available indirect firepower.
Those kinds of losses do not work out well for Russia in the long run, especially when artillery can have a substantial impact on the outcomes of battles.
Counteroffensive operations, of course, are more than the counter-battery fight alone, and Ukraine’s artillery, specifically massed fires as opposed to precision strike, will have other roles to play, as Patrick Hinton, a serving officer in the British Army’s Royal Artillery, explained in commentary for RUSI.
A major challenge to the Ukrainian counteroffensive are the layers of extensive defensive fortifications Russia constructed prior to its start and consisting of tank traps and barriers and minefields backed by entrenched infantry, air power, and Russian indirect fire support.
Hinton, Chief of the General Staff’s Visiting Fellow in the Military Sciences Research Group at RUSI, wrote “it should not be understated how difficult it is to overcome a well thought-out and resourced defensive operation.”
In addition to countering enemy artillery, Ukraine will need to use its artillery to suppress defenses and support infantry maneuvers, such as assault and trench-clearing operations, by forcing the Russians to take cover during a barrage and hindering their ability to fire at the advancing force.
Beyond the physical destruction, artillery also has a tremendous psychological effect in battle. For advancing offensive forces, it can be a “crucial confidence boost,” Hinton wrote, and for troops on defense, it is simply “terrifying.”
“The noise, smell and shaking ground of a volley of shells exploding in close proximity provides a very effective distraction while friendly troops advance,” he wrote, explaining that “immense fear is a sure-fire way to reduce the combat effectiveness of enemy soldiers.”
Russian artillery can have the same effect on Ukraine though if left unanswered, which is a reason why the counter-battery fight matters.
Counteroffensive operations are a challenge to execute even with sufficient air power and long-range strike capabilities, which Ukraine does not have. The last thing they need is enemy artillery raining down on advancing forces.
But if Ukraine can support its maneuver forces “with its artillery guns and exploit the nuances within the art of fires,” Hinton said, “it will provide a significant advantage as its forces undertake one of the more difficult military endeavours.”

Imagine the destruction that Ukraine could rain down on the orcs, if the WH, would untie the shackles on Ukraine, and actually give it weapons to win this fucking war.
I sympathize with Ukraine. I admire the courage of its people. I lose sleep over this war, even from my safe place here in America. More than anything, I want Ukraine to have every weapon they need to get the job done. However, I do get a little frustrated when the US is criticized by people with limited, relevant knowledge. Ukraine is not the only country that needs help, although it is the most pressing issue at this time. The United States recognizes that the Taiwan/China problem can pose a serious threat to democracy, which I’m sure Putin would love. Now, I don’t have any more insight into the global dynamics of all this no more than you do, but I trust someone in Biden’s orbit does. One final thought/question: Would Ukraine prefer dealing with Trump?
If the US threw it’s full weight behind Ukraine to defeat russia, there would be no China/Taiwan problem.
If you say so, Scooter.
What’s the reason for being disrespectful? Do you have a problem allowing different perspectives than your own? It is likely if the west threw everything they had behind Ukraine, the commies in China and Moskovia would say WTF?!!
As far as Trump goes, putin invaded while Biden was VP and then invaded full on while Biden was president. Those are the facts….Donald.
If Trump was in office he would have a Hotel in Kiev named after Putin. Fact.
Fact #2: You suck-up to Trump about as much as Trump sucked-up to Putin. And that is weird.
Don, you are saying some weird things. Maybe you shouldn’t drink so much.
You have clearly lost your mind. Do you even have a job?
That’s a fact, little guy.
I also agree with you about this. Because America is sending military aid to an active war zone, I feel like this is making china pause on invading Taiwan. Even if the military aid is a bit half-assed.
It baffles the mind that so many people cannot connect the dots to understand this fact.
I actually agree with you, for nearly everything you point out here. Except for one thing. For all the frustrations these good people have here with Trump, and for all my disappointments in him, this war didn’t start because of Trump. Nor did any hostilities restart during his presidency.
This all started during obama’s bureaucracy, and restarted after biden’s hasty retreat from Afghanistan. Trump did start negotiations with the taliban, and I think that made the cave-dwelling taliban more bolder to try rapid advances in movement. Much more so, when biden showed how easily panicked and fearful he would be when backed into a corner. Just prior to the invasion, putin massed over 100,000 troops near the Ukrainian border, with armored vehicles, tanks, artillery, and all the equipment that looked like preparations for an invasion. But of course, putin called it “training maneuvers.” ALL on BIDEN’s watch. What did biden do? He pointed to it, saying something to effect of, “That looks dangerous somebody ought to confront putin.” But that’s all biden did, up to the start of russians getting across the border and moving deeper into Ukrainian territory.
Even though he is actually doing something for Ukraine, I still have NO TRUST in biden, after he became a paper tiger in the Afghanistan retreat. There were actually young Afghans falling off the wheels of the American transport planes because they left so fast, at the cost of 13 AMERICAN SOLDIERS DYING from taliban attacks during the evacuation, and biden left behind hundreds of millions of dollars in military equipment for the taliban to take over. Afghanistan isn’t the same as Ukraine, of course. But biden is NOT a strategic thinker, or even a critical one for honesty in doubts. I’m NOT voting for biden to even tell me what the weather will be like tomorrow, let alone to run my country.
“Counteroffensive operations are a challenge to execute even with sufficient air power and long-range strike capabilities, which Ukraine does not have. The last thing they need is enemy artillery raining down on advancing forces.”
It’s already too late. History books will contain every weakness and failure that the West has shown in this war, and the most serious one of all is not providing modern Western aircraft to the struggling nation. In terms of military aid and sanctions, the allies have stumbled, bumbled, and floundered along a pathway that was strewn with fear, confusion and indecision.
It’s only through Ukraine’s incredible bravery, determination, and ingenuity that this war hasn’t been lost a long time ago already. Yes, it’s also thanks in a very large part to military aid by its friends. But, with a more determined aid program, the war could already have been won. Instead, it hasn’t been lost yet.
“Russia has lost four artillery pieces for every one that Ukraine has lost,…”
That unfortunately barely maintains parity.
Similarly Ukraine needs a 4-1 kill rate just to maintain parity.
The foul scum won’t leave until it becomes untenable for them. IMO that means the defenders need to take out a minimum of 3000 orcs each and every day.
A couple of of months of that and the scum will slither back to their nazi shitholes.
The sooner that Ukraine’s allies realise that, the better.
In his article, Boris estimates; presumably from available intel, that the defenders have lost 100,000 troops; a truly terrible amount. And God knows how many civilians; including children.
If 100,000 Ukrainian defenders have died, that leaves a huge amount of fighters with terrible physical and mental trauma.
Imagine how they will feel after the war, when they see men of their own age who didn’t fight, enjoying themselves with their girlfriends without a care in the world?
Putinazi vermin have already inflicted enough death, misery and horror on Ukrainians for the next 100 years.
We can of course forget Nato. It is up to the US, UK and Poland to bring this horror to a quick end.
By any means necessary. Boots on the ground, planes in the air and ships and subs in the sea.
As much as I dislike Bush 1 for the way he treated Ukraine during the critical days of our independence (I may be taking liberties I shouldn’t be taking by saying “our” but at this point I feel as much Ukrainian as I do as being an American) at least Bush understood the what war was about. When Iraq invaded Kuwait, overwhelming force was used and the mess was cleaned up in months. Sure allot of mistakes were made whether we should have taken out the Iraqi regime at that time or other issues but nonetheless, the world saw the force and the message…don’t fuck with us. What has happened in the thirty years that have followed? Don’t the political leaders learn from history or are they just moronic idiots? God save us all
Yes. Completely agree here. I wonder if a lot of modern conveniences, and cultural attitudes to be more “accepting” of laziness have contributed significantly to this.
Awesome user profile icon by the way. 😎
No, Mike, they are indeed moronic idiots. They prove it every day.