Russia’s massive Black Sea problem is worse than it looks

Click to Enlarge. The Russian naval base in Novorossiysk is under constant threat from Ukrainian uncrewed surface vessels (USVs), autonomous underwater vehicles (AUVs), and uncrewed arial vehicles (UAVs).

On paper, the Russian Navy remains the dominant force in the Black Sea. But after ceding control to Ukraine’s uncrewed surface drones, it now faces a mounting crisis: its key base at Novorossiysk is increasingly untenable, unless Moscow is willing to absorb further warship losses.

Dramatic drone footage captures a Ukrainian strike on a Russian Navy frigate, underscoring the precision and resolve of Ukraine’s unmanned forces.  The April 5th attack, part of a wider air raid on the Russian Black Sea port of Novorossiysk, adds to the already lengthy highlight reel of the war.

Yet it points to a deeper reality in the Black Sea. Russian Navy vessels are no longer safe in the base at Novorossiysk. Having relocating from Sevastopol to evade Ukrainian strikes, they now face comparable threat levels in what was once considered a safe haven. But they have a problem, where to go?

The Ukrainian strike on the Russian frigate

The Pr.11356M Grigorvich-class ship, likely Admiral Essen, is one of only two Russian frigates in the Black Sea. Since the sinking of the Slava-class cruiser Moskva on April 14, 2022 they have been the largest warships in the Russia’s fleet and a strategic asset. Armed with Kalibr cruise missiles, they have frequently participated in missile strikes on Ukraine. They can launch their missiles without leaving port, and it seems possible that that is what this vessel was preparing to do. It was berthed along the outer sea wall instead of its usual berth much deeper inside the base. 

Ukraine’s strike drones (OWA-UAVs) reached deep into Russian territory. They flew in from the seaward side to strike the important frigate. Other drones successfully hit the oil export infrastructure nearby, causing massive fires which lit up the nighttime sky. A hail of Russian missiles and anti-aircraft fire, assisted by spotlights, couldn’t keep them at bay. 

A fleet in being

The Russian Black Sea Fleet is confined to Novorossiysk. Threatened by a plethora of uncrewed surface vessels (USVs), underwater drones (AUVs) and aerial drones (UAVs), they rarely venture out of port. The submarines often submerge at their berths to reduce their visibility to drones. 

Now the protective seawalls of Novorossiysk are becoming a cage. The increasing accuracy and confidence of Ukrainian drone forces makes it only a matter of time before more serious damage is inflicted. 

Nowhere to run to

Nestled in a mountainous inlet on Russia’s Black Sea coast, Novorossiysk is between 200-350 nautical miles from Ukrainian held territory. Yet it is now firmly in the crosshairs, threatened by surface, sub-surface and aerial drones. The latter, Ukraine’s long-range strike drones, are being a dominant force.

Russia’s problem is that there is no other port to retreat to in the Black Sea. The port at Sochi, or across the border at Ochamchire in Georgia, are both small and offer limited facilities. And retreating through the Volga-Don Canal to the Caspian Sea may be irreversible.

It may therefore be only a matter of time before they are compelled to return to sea, exchanging their vulnerability to aerial drones in port for the persistent threat of USVs offshore.  In a war where Russia is famously fighting a country ‘without a navy’, every ship lost will be a humiliation. So, the Russian sailors must succeed against every single incoming threat. But the Ukrainians, using expendable uncrewed platforms, only have to get lucky once.

Picture of H I Sutton

H I Sutton

H I Sutton writes about the secretive and under-reported submarines, seeking out unusual and interesting vessels and technologies involved in fighting beneath the waves. Submarines, capabilities, naval special forces underwater vehicles and the changing world of underwater warfare and seabed warfare. To do this he combines the latest Open Source Intelligence (OSINT) with the traditional art and science of defense analysis. He occasionally writes non-fiction books on these topics and draws analysis-based illustrations to bring the subject to life. In addition, H I Sutton is a naval history buff and data geek. His personal website about these topics is Covert Shores (www.hisutton.com)

About Naval News :

https://www.navalnews.com/about-us/

4 comments

  1. DT this morning:

    US and Iran fail to reach peace deal, says Vance

    “Peace talks between the United States and Iran have collapsed without an agreement to end the war.

    JD Vance, the US vice-president, addressed the media after 21 hours of historic negotiations in Islamabad.

    He said: “The bad news is that we have not reached an agreement, and I think that’s bad news for Iran much more than it’s bad news for the United States of America.”

    Mr Vance told reporters just after 6am local time (3am UK) that the US delegation was leaving after putting forward a “final and best offer” that the Iranians had “chosen not to accept”.

    • Vance is an idiot. The bad news counts for the U.S., too. Today’s official average price for gas in the U.S. is $4.12, so rekindling the shooting will make it go up even more. The cost of this war is also not to be ignored, especially given our already extremely high national debt. And we are still babes in the woods when it comes to drone warfare, regardless of what this incompetent and treasonous administration claims, which will real dangers for our soldiers and sailors.
      All of this is not good news for the Taco administration.

  2. A nation without a real navy has chased the “second navy” in the world out of Sevastopol and back to its shithole, and now even the shithole is being made unsafe by the country without a navy. Can you make this up? 😂

  3. This is a real nice heart warming story. The choice to get out of the Black Sea or face further ships being destroyed. Either way it’s a humiliation.

Enter comments here: