Ukraine’s spy problem runs deeper than Volodymyr Zelensky’s childhood friend

The Ukrainian president’s recent swathe of sackings reveals a government blighted by treachery, collaboration and internal rivalries

SENIOR FOREIGN CORRESPONDENT 18 July 2022 •

It is a conversation that has been repeated in Kyiv for months.

“When this is over, there will be questions to answer,” one Kyiv resident told me in May. “Questions like: how did they take the South so quickly?”

Those suspicions of treachery burst into the open on Sunday when the Security Service of Ukraine (SBU) arrested Oleh Kulinych, its own former chief of Crimean affairs, on suspicion of high treason.

Hours later, Volodymyr Zelensky unceremoniously dismissed Ivan Bakanov, the country’s chief spy, and Irina Venediktova, the prosecutor general, citing the large number of staff at both agencies in occupied territories who switched sides to work with Russia.

Their suspensions are technically temporary and, if exonerated, they may eventually return to their posts.

But the dramatic reshuffle – the most significant since the war began – reflects growing frustration in government over the performance of the country’s security service and concerns about penetration by Russian spies.

It also exposes long-running, pre-war political tensions that have been largely set aside after the February 24 invasion.

Fatal decisions led to dismissals

Mr Zelensky appointed Mr Bakanov, a childhood friend, to head the sprawling SBU in 2019. Like the president, Mr Bakanov’s background was in show business, not espionage, and the appointment was widely criticised as inappropriate.

Ivan Bakanov Ukraine's Security Service head at a security conference
Ukraine’s top spy chief Ivan Bakanov faces investigations into his conduct CREDIT: Efrem Lukatsky/AP

But the SBU had been struck by a series of scandals and there was an argument that someone from outside the shadowy security world would be better placed to act as a new broom.

With around 30,000 agents, the successor agency to the KGB is seven times the size of MI5 and has a vast brief that extends from counter-terrorism to fighting organised crime to running espionage and counter-espionage operations.

It has long had a reputation for unaccountability and penetration by Russian spies, and Mr Bakanov told MPs that he would need three years to reform it.

His dismissal on Sunday for “non-performance of duties leading to human casualties or other serious consequences” reflects a sense in Mr Zelensky’s Kyiv office that he failed.

Vasyl Maliuk, the temporary replacement appointed on Monday, is a career security service officer.

High ranking officials charged with treason

Mr Kulinych, the former head of the SBU’s Crimea operations, is the latest in a series of high-ranking officers to be charged with treason since the war began.

Mr Zelensky dismissed Andriy Naumov, the head of the agency’s internal security department, and Serhiy Kryvoruchko, the head of the SBU’s Kherson office, on March 31.

Mr Naumov, who is accused of fleeing the country hours before the invasion began, was arrested in Serbia on June 7 on suspicion of money laundering. He was carrying hundreds of thousands of euros and dollars in cash and at least two emeralds. Ukraine is seeking his extradition.

Mr Kryvoruchko, who is accused of ordering his men, against Mr Zelensky’s orders, to evacuate Kherson as the Russians approached, is in Ukrainian custody. So is Ihor Sadokhin, one of his deputies, who has been charged with handing the Russians a map of Ukrainian minefields and coordinating their air operations even as he drove away from the city in the evacuation convoy.

Russian troops standing guard at a power plant near Kherson, Ukraine
Russian troops have occupied Kherson in southern Ukraine since its capture on March 3 CREDIT: Sergei Ilnitsky/Shutterstock

The role of suspected collaborators in the rapid Russian progress in the south of the country during the first week of the war has been one of the most hotly debated topics in Ukraine. 

While Russian armour was held up outside Kyiv in the north and Kharkiv in the east, its southern task force burst out of Crimea almost unopposed and by March 3 had captured Kherson, a strategic city on the Dnipro river.

Speculation has swirled ever since about Russia’s apparent prior knowledge of Ukraine’s minefields, and Ukraine’s failure to fight at the narrow isthmus linking Crimea to the mainland, or to blow up a key bridge in Kherson.

Pre-war political tensions exposed

Followers of Ukrainian politics will note that there are also internal political rivalries at play.

Mrs Vendiktova’s replacement as chief prosecutor, Oleksii Simonenko, is seen as close to Andreii Yermak, Mr Zelensky’s chief of staff.

Mr Yermak is an often controversial figure who over the years has been accused by civil society activists of a range of misdeeds including stalling anti-corruption reforms, sabotaging a 2020 operation to arrest Russian Wagner mercenaries, and being generally too close to Russia.

No evidence has emerged. But those allegations, many of them years old, were resurrected last week when an American congresswoman wrote to Joe Biden demanding to know why the US was working with him.

On July 8, Representative Victoria Spartz of Indiana, who was born in Ukraine, asked Mr Biden to brief congress on “due diligence and oversight procedures” regarding Mr Yermak and Oleh Tatarov, his deputy for law enforcement and anti-corruption reform.

The letter drew a furious response from Kyiv, with the Ukrainian foreign ministry accusing Ms Spartz of fuelling Russian “propaganda” designed to undermine confidence in the government.

The man appointed to replace Mrs Venediktova, Oleksei Simonenko, is widely accused of stalling an investigation into alleged bribery by Mr Tatarov by the National Anti Corruption Bureau (NABU) by handing it over to the SBU – a move NABU said was illegal.

Hunting traitors and Russian spies is one thing. Navigating Ukraine’s infamously fractious domestic politics is quite another.

8 comments

  1. “Speculation has swirled ever since about Russia’s apparent prior knowledge of Ukraine’s minefields, and Ukraine’s failure to fight at the narrow isthmus linking Crimea to the mainland, or to blow up a key bridge in Kherson.”

    This is very painful for Ukrainians and a sad failure which will unfortunately require the shedding of lots of Ukrainian blood to take back this vital piece of land.
    Once Kherson oblast is safe and secure, things will look a hell of a lot better for the defenders.

    Liked by 5 people

  2. “Mr Zelensky appointed Mr Bakanov, a childhood friend, to head the sprawling SBU in 2019.”

    This measure was one of numerous ones that made us call Zelensky a clown. It was indeed an appropriate one. Now, it’s coming back to haunt him and this in the most inopportune time!

    “The role of suspected collaborators in the rapid Russian progress in the south of the country during the first week of the war has been one of the most hotly debated topics in Ukraine.”

    As it should be! The Crimean isthmus should’ve been the easiest place to defend against mafia land, but it fell the quickest. There was treason involved, no doubt about it whatsoever.

    “Hunting traitors and Russian spies is one thing. Navigating Ukraine’s infamously fractious domestic politics is quite another.”

    We’ve seen many problems with Zelensky’s government before the full-blown war started. Although he’s doing a great job now, the gross mistakes that were made before are now making this job more difficult than it already is. There needs to be a tough response to any sort of treason and spying since the nation’s very existence is at stake. I hope that Zelensky and those who are loyal to the country fully comprehend this.

    Liked by 4 people

    • There have been a lot of rumblings on social media etc, as to why the exit from Crimea was de-mined just before the orcs invaded. They took the South way too quickly, so they must have had inside help.

      Liked by 4 people

    • It was Zelensky’s fault to begin with. He appointed these people, against a lot of well meaning advice too. He can’t blame anyone else.

      Liked by 2 people

      • Sir Focusser it’s not a blame game right now. We’re in trouble. I don’t know how we get out of this mess and conduct a war at the same time. It’s troubling to me.

        Liked by 2 people

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.