Russian oligarchs prepare for London defamation hearing with legal teams set to cash in

In a rare statement, Roman Abramovich insisted he was reluctantly bringing the case because of a failure to find an ‘amicable resolution’

By Robert Mendick, CHIEF REPORTER

24 July 2021

Four Russian oligarchs including Roman Abramovich will make an application to court this week in what will undoubtedly become the defamation case to watch when it comes to trial.

They are bringing a case against Catherine Belton and the published of her best-selling investigative book, “Putin’s People: How the KGB Took Back Russia and Then Took on the West”.

Teams of solicitors, QCs and junior barristers will collectively earn millions of pounds in fees in what may prove to be the most lucrative libel case in British legal history.

Ms Belton is being sued personally by Abramovich, the owner of Chelsea Football Club, and Shalva Chigirinsky, an oil and property tycoon, as well as by Rosneft, Russia’s state-owned oil and gas company.

HarperCollins, the book’s publisher, is also being sued by all three, along with two other Russian billionaires, Mikhail Fridman and Petr Aven. Aven, however, is suing for alleged data protection breaches rather than libel.

The lawsuits were filed in a flurry of activity over a three-week period between March and April this year, just under a year after the book was first published in hardback. The High Court ordered them to be heard at the same time.

Pay day for the lawyers

Mrs Justice Tipples, sitting in the High Court, will on Wednesday hear legal arguments to determine allegedly defamatory allegations made by Ms Belton in her book.

How the judge interprets passages in the book will play a large part in determining the success of the various claims brought by the Russian billionaires.

The case represents a bumper pay day for London’s highly paid defamation lawyers, who can charge as much as £750 an hour for advice.

‘Claimant friendly’ laws

The litigation will be eagerly watched by campaigners who believe the London courts – and England’s ‘claimant friendly’ libel laws – are being too often used to try to gag investigative journalists, acting in the public interest.

Jessica Ní Mhainín, head of policy at the Index on Censorship, a group that campaigns for free expression, said: “We are extremely concerned that UK defamation laws, which are notoriously claimant friendly, are having a chilling effect on investigative journalism around the world. We cannot allow this to continue.”

Bill Browder, a businessman and the driving force behind new sanctions laws in the US and UK against Russian individuals, said: “This threatens to be the biggest legal pile on I’ve ever seen and it risks deterring future journalists from writing about Putin’s wealth. English libel laws need to be amended to prevent these cases being brought in the future.”

Harbottle & Lewis, a law firm that has acted for members of the Royal family in recent media law cases, has been hired by Abramovich. In a statement issued in March, the law firm said it was issuing proceedings relating “to a number of false and defamatory claims made about our client”. 

The law firm said the book “falsely alleges that our client has acted corruptly, and makes false claims about our client’s purchase, and the activities, of Chelsea Football Club”.

Abramovich statement

In a rare statement Abramovich, who is worth an estimated £10.7 billion, insisted he was reluctantly bringing the legal case because of a failure to find an “amicable resolution”.

He said: “Unfortunately, these engagements were not successful, and the publisher has not corrected the false statements in the book.”

Nine days after Abramovich filed his claim, Rosneft, with a market capitalisation according to Forbes of £56.5 billion, lodged its case in the High Court.

The oil conglomerate, based in Moscow, is the largest company in Russia. A day later on April 1, Fridman, worth £11.2 billion after making his fortune in banking, sued HarperCollins for libel, and nine days after that Aven, a business partner of Fridman with an estimated £3.8 billion fortune, lodged a claim for breach of data protection laws.

The last of the claims was filed by Shalva Chigirinsky, an oil tycoon, who has hired the law firm Taylor Wessing. Fridman and Aven are both using the same law firm CMS Cameron Mckenna Nabarro Olswang, while Rosneft is represented by libel law specialists Carter Ruck.

All the claims were issued independently of each other and the Russian claimants are insistent that there has been no coordinated strategic plan to derail Ms Belton’s book. 

Ms Belton’s legal costs are covered by HarperCollins, which was bought by Rupert Murdoch’s News Corp in 1989. HarperCollins has described Ms Belton’s book as an “authoritative, important and conscientiously sourced work”.

In a statement, the firm has said: “We will robustly defend this acclaimed and groundbreaking book and the right to report on matters of considerable public interest.”

Court documents show that Abramovich’s libel suit disputes a claim that Putin ordered his 2003 acquisition of Chelsea for political purposes. The book’s on the record source for the claim is Sergei Pugachev, an exiled Russian billionaire who was once a member of Putin’s inner circle before falling out and forced to flee the country.

In a case in 2017, a High Court judge described Pugachev as an unreliable witness.

In a statement issued to the Financial Times in May, a spokesperson for Mr Fridman has said: “We can confirm that neither Mr Aven nor Mr Fridman had any prior knowledge of the other lawsuits you have referred to. They have had no contact with, and did not coordinate a legal strategy with, the other plaintiffs or their lawyers.”

4 comments

  • “Bill Browder, a businessman and the driving force behind new sanctions laws in the US and UK against Russian individuals, said: “This threatens to be the biggest legal pile on I’ve ever seen and it risks deterring future journalists from writing about Putin’s wealth. English libel laws need to be amended to prevent these cases being brought in the future.”

    Bill is right. The idea of supposedly respectable law firms prostituting themselves for a murderous fascist regime makes me sick. I sincerely hope that the judges chuck this out.

    Abramovich has been putler’s right hand man for years, has been allowed to use London as a money laundering centre for the past 20 years or so. All his cash, business and property assets in London, including CFC, should be seized and, after paying compensation to the many thousands of families whose loved ones were murdered by the little dictator’s invasions, any remaining should be used to help Ukraine, Georgia and Moldova defend themselves from imperialist Russia. 

    Liked by 3 people

    • onlyfactsplease

      Indeed, sir Scradge, this would be a tremendous step forward in combating the rat’s nest that is mafia land. Seize all assets from every fascist-crime syndicate supporter, asap and in full and make good use of them. But, I’m afraid that this will never happen. Too many are hanging on this fat sow’s titts, sucking down their share of the spoils.

      Liked by 3 people

    • If a writer is found libel in GB for writing the truth then GB has a free speech problem that needs to be remedied. It seems just fine that people can write lies and get away with it

      Liked by 2 people

  • I have no problem with “loser pays” in the British system. I do have a problem with the libel laws which require the author to prove the truth of what they say. Abuse is far too easy, as we have been seeing over the last 30 years.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.