Judge rules MH17 accused can’t claim ‘combatant immunity’ defence

A Dutch prosecutor says four men accused of murder over the downing of MH17 can’t claim combatant immunity because they weren’t fighting for a state.

Four men accused of murder over the downing of Malaysia Airlines flight 17 in eastern Ukraine can’t claim combatant immunity, a Dutch court has heard.

Prosecutor Ward Ferdinandusse says Russian Oleg Pulatov, Igor Girkin, Sergey Dubinsky and Leonid Kharchenko, who are being tried in absentia, weren’t fighting for a recognised state when the passenger plane was shot down with a missile on July 17, 2014.

He told the District Court of The Hague on Wednesday the four are therefore criminally responsible for the murder of all 298 aboard, including 38 who called Australia home.

“According to the Dutch criminal law you are not allowed to shoot down aeroplanes and kill persons irrespective of whether these are civilians or military persons,” Ferdinandusse said.

“In those cases, the crimes qualify as murder and downing an aeroplane causing death.”

Debris of Malaysia Arilines flight MH17, which crashed in eastern Ukraine near Donetsk
Source AAP

The prosecution explained that fighters needed to satisfy five tests to claim combatant immunity under the Geneva Convention.

They must prove they fought for a state in an international conflict, they were under the command structure of a state, they were subject to a military disciplinary system in line with humanitarian law, they distinguished themselves from civilians and they acted in line with humanitarian law.

Ferdinandusse says the accused four for groups that inflicted “a reign of intimidation and terror” in eastern Ukraine including extrajudicial killings of civilians.

“Their group used lawless violence that is banned by the laws of war. Just for that reason alone, they do not qualify for immunity,” he told the court.

The prosecution said the four accused had consistently denied fighting for Russia, even though it supplied them with fighters, weapons and logistical support during the conflict.

Russia has also denied there was an international armed conflict in Ukraine, that it was involved and that separatists were under its command or acting on its behalf.

But Ferdinandusse left the door open for Pulatov to claim he was acting for Russia, which is unlikely because it would directly implicate the Russian government in the MH17 disaster.

“The first and most important question that has to be answered by Pulatov if he wants claim combatant immunity is whether or not in July 2014 he was part of Russian armed forces,” he said.

“If Pulatov has read the case file and also conducted additional investigations to find out that he was part of the Russian armed forces in 2014 he will probably be the first person in the world who only found out years afterwards that he was actually part of an army.

“If Pulatov doesn’t know himself or cannot substantiate that at the time he belonged to the Russian forces we can safely assume that that was not the case.”

The trial continues.

(c) SBS News


  • “If Pulatov doesn’t know himself or cannot substantiate that at the time he belonged to the Russian forces we can safely assume that that was not the case.”

    If Pulatov claims he was fighting for Russia, the defense lawyers could go home, they would have no client to defend.

    Liked by 5 people

  • onlyfactsplease

    Combatant immunity comes into effect when there was a declaration of war. Mafia land “isn’t involved” in Donbass, right? At least not rightfully.

    Liked by 3 people

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.